Preventing Patent Risks in Artificial Intelligence Industry for Sustainable Development: A Multi-Level Network Analysis

Abstract

In recent years, assessing patent risks has attracted fast-growing attention from both researchers and practitioners in studies of technological innovation. Following the existing literature on risks and intellectual property (IP) risks, we define patent risks as the lack of understanding of the distribution of patents that lead to losing a key patent, increased research and development costs, and, potentially, infringement litigation. This paper aims to propose an explorative approach to investigating patent risks in the target technology field by integrating social network analysis and patent analysis. Compared to previous research, this study makes an important contribution toward identifying patent risks in the overall technological field by employing a patent-based multi-level network model that has not appeared in existing methodologies of patent risks. In order to verify the effectiveness of this approach, we take artificial intelligence (AI) as an example. Data collected from the Derwent Innovation Index (DII) database were used to build the patent-based multi-level network on patent risks from market, technology, and assignee perspectives. The results indicate that the lack of international collaborations among assignees and industry–university–research collaboration may lead to patent collaboration risks. Regarding patent market risks, the lack of overseas patent applications, especially the lack of distribution in the main competitive markets, is a key factor. As for patent technology risks, most of the leading assignees lack awareness of the distribution in the following technological fields: industrial electric equipment, engineering instrumentation, and automotive electrics. In summary, assignees from the U.S. with first mover advantages are still powerful leaders in the AI technology field. Although China is catching up very rapidly in the total number of AI patents, the apparent patent risks under the perspectives of collaboration, market, and technology will obviously hamper the catch-up efforts of China’s AI industry. We conclude that, in practice, the proposed patent-based multi-level network model not only plays an important role in helping stakeholders in the AI technological field to prevent patent risks, find new technology opportunities, and obtain sustainable development, but also has significance for guiding the industrial development of various emerging technology fields.

Exploring the Technological Changes of Green Agriculture in China: Evidence from Patent Data (1998–2021)

“…Period 3 saw a peak in the number of patents, but there were also instances of negative growth. By period 4, there is a general downward trend in the number of patents, which may be due to the time delay between patent application and grant [47]. In addition, technology iteration also requires a certain amount of time for R&D reserves.…”

The Silicon Valley Bank Failure: Application of Benford’s Law to Spot Abnormalities and Risks

“…The stock price of the holding firm rose throughout the bubble but plunged 50% after it crashed. The bank expanded its presence in technological hotspots (Yang and Yu 2020) around the globe. Ken Wilcox became CEO in 2000 and decided to keep the company's exclusive emphasis on technology providers (Dutta et al 2023b;Dutta and Saha 2022) instead of broadening into a commercial and industrial financial institution.…”

A novel approach to screening patents for securitization: a machine learning-based predictive analysis of high-quality basic asset

“…The IncoPat database introduces the Derwent World Patents Index (DWPI) to localize DWPI data and provide authoritative and accurate data for Chinese users. DWPI is a global comprehensive database of deep-processing enhanced patent information and a comprehensive database of patent documents, which is widely used in research (Yang and Yu, 2020). The CSMAR database is also the largest and most accurate and comprehensive economic and financial research database in China, so the data quality can be guaranteed.…”