Prevalence and Therapy Rates for Stuttering, Cluttering, and Developmental Disorders of Speech and Language: Evaluation of German Health Insurance Data

Abstract

PurposeTo evaluate the prevalence and treatment patterns of speech and language disorders in Germany.MethodsA retrospective analysis of data collected from 32% of the German population, insured by the statutory German health insurance (AOK, Local Health Care Funds). We used The International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th revision, German Modification (ICD-10 GM) codes for stuttering (F98.5), cluttering (F98.6), and developmental disorders of speech and language (F80) to identify prevalent and newly diagnosed cases each year. Prescription and speech therapy reimbursement data were used to evaluate treatment patterns.ResultsIn 2017, 27,977 patients of all ages were diagnosed with stuttering (21,045 males, 75% and 6,932 females, 25%). Stuttering prevalence peaks at age 5 years (boys, 0.89% and girls, 0.40%). Cluttering was diagnosed in 1,800 patients of all ages (1,287 males, 71.5% and 513 females, 28.5%). Developmental disorders of speech and language were identified in 555,774 AOK-insurants (61.2% males and 38.8% females). Treatment data indicate a substantial proportion newly diagnosed stuttering individuals receive treatment (up to 45% of 6-year-old patients), with slightly fewer than 20 sessions per year, on average. We confirmed a previous study showing increased rates of atopic disorders and neurological and psychiatric comorbidities in individuals with stuttering, cluttering, and developmental disorders of speech and language.ConclusionThis is the first nationwide study using health insurance data to analyze the prevalence and newly diagnosed cases of a speech and language disorder. Prevalence and gender ratio data were consistent with the international literature. The crude prevalence of developmental disorders of speech and language increased from 2015 to 2018, whereas the crude prevalence for stuttering remained stable. For cluttering, the numbers were too low to draw reliable conclusions. Proportional treatment allocation for stuttering peaked at 6 years of age, which is the school entrance year, and is later than the prevalence peak of stuttering.

Cognitive disorders in childhood epilepsy: a comparative longitudinal study using administrative healthcare data

“…Although only 17.4% of our cases had cognitive impairment, their risk for cognitive impairment compared to children without epilepsy was increased by a factor of about ten. A recent claim-based analysis on developmental speech and language disorders revealed a high prevalence in epileptic patients’ age 0–19 years [ 31 ]. Given the close association between language development and cognition, these results supports or our findings.…”

Applications of mindfulness and/or compassion interventions for people who stutter: A systematic review

“…The prevalence of stuttering after adolescence may be as low as 0.5% (Craig et al, 2002) or even lower (Sommer et al, 2021), and a proportion of people who stutter seeking treatment is even lower. Therefore, it may be difficult to accumulate group design studies such as RCTs and establish evidence for the interventions.…”

The ACM Multimedia 2022 Computational Paralinguistics Challenge

“…In the Stuttering Sub-Challenge, parts (KSF-C) of the Kassel State of Fluency corpus [6,7] are used. Stuttering is a complex speech disorder with a crude prevalence of about 1 % of the population [34]. Monitoring of stuttering would allow objective feedback to persons who stutter (PWS) and speech therapists, thus facilitating tailored speech therapy, with the automatic detection of different stuttering phenomena as a necessary prerequisite.…”