Prevalence and costs of defensive medicine: a national survey of Italian physicians

Abstract

Objective To identify the prevalence of the practice of defensive medicine among Italian hospital physicians, its costs and the reasons for practising defensive medicine and possible solutions to reduce the practice of defensive medicine. Methods Cross-sectional web survey. Main outcome measures Number of physicians reporting having engaged in any defensive medicine behaviour in the previous year. Results A total of 1313 physicians completed the survey. Ninety-five per cent believed that defensive medicine would increase in the near future. The practice of defensive medicine accounted for approximately 10% of total annual Italian national health expenditure. Conclusions Defensive medicine is a significant factor in health care costs without adding any benefit to patients. The economic burden of defensive medicine on health care systems should provide a substantial stimulus for a prompt review of this situation in a time of economic crisis. Malpractice reform, together with a systematic use of evidence-based clinical guidelines, is likely to be the most effective way to reduce defensive medicine.

The first survey on defensive medicine among Iranian surgeons: prevalence and its related factors

“…The current cross sectional study was conducted in Tehran, 2017 and the study population included the surgeons participating in the 41st Iranian Association of Surgeons congress. Based on the previous studies, the prevalence of DM behaviors was estimated 80% [1,9]. Therefore, taking into account p=0.8 and d =0.05, the sample size was estimated 245.…”

“…Throughout the world, due to increased medical claims, the culture of defensive medicine is growing [4]. In the United States, about 93% of the physicians make DM behaviors [8] while 78% and 56% of the physicians in the UK [1] and Italy [9] hospitals, respectively, use some kind of defensive behaviors in their medical practice.…”

Integrated care pathways on dementia in Italy: a survey testing the compliance with a national guidance

“…In fact, the presence of adequate indicators was associated with higher levels of appropriateness of the ICPs in terms of adequate clinical definition of the target population, and adequate management of cases based on disease severity, especially when applying of the best available therapeutic options. The presence of clinical outcome indicators was also associated with an active involvement of clinicians, who are immediately able to assess the relevance of the pathway based on the A recent survey carried out among Italian clinicians pointed out that 378 out of 785 physicians (48.2%), from 3 different Italian regions, consider the systematic use of guidelines or care pathways as the best solution to reduce or avoid the recourse to defensive medicine [34]. In fact, the recent, dramatic increase clinicians adopting a defensive medicine approach could have been responsible for the parallel increase in the costs linked to medical malpractice and/or claims from insurance companies.…”

“…In fact, the recent, dramatic increase clinicians adopting a defensive medicine approach could have been responsible for the parallel increase in the costs linked to medical malpractice and/or claims from insurance companies. This, along with the progressively lower budget allocated to healthcare, might have a negative impact on the burden and sustainability of national public health services [34,35]. Therefore, policy-makers and decision-makers must take into consideration the need to improve and support the implementation of good practices, in order to provide the most appropriate and adequate healthcare services.…”

Defensive Surgery - a New Under-Recognized Reality among Surgeons?

“…Defensive medicine is a widespread approach among physicians all over the world. Defensive medicine is defi ned either by ordering of extra-investigations, tests or procedures (assurance behavior), or by avoidance of high-risk patients or procedures (avoidance behavior), for the purpose of reducing the risks of being accused for malpractice 1,2 . Defensive medicine is characterized as the deviation of the medical behavior from medical protocols and recognized guidelines.…”