Preserving the Impossible: Conservation of Soft-Sediment Hominin Footprint Sites and Strategies for Three-Dimensional Digital Data Capture

Abstract

Human footprints provide some of the most publically emotive and tangible evidence of our ancestors. To the scientific community they provide evidence of stature, presence, behaviour and in the case of early hominins potential evidence with respect to the evolution of gait. While rare in the geological record the number of footprint sites has increased in recent years along with the analytical tools available for their study. Many of these sites are at risk from rapid erosion, including the Ileret footprints in northern Kenya which are second only in age to those at Laetoli (Tanzania). Unlithified, soft-sediment footprint sites such these pose a significant geoconservation challenge. In the first part of this paper conservation and preservation options are explored leading to the conclusion that to ‘record and digitally rescue’ provides the only viable approach. Key to such strategies is the increasing availability of three-dimensional data capture either via optical laser scanning and/or digital photogrammetry. Within the discipline there is a developing schism between those that favour one approach over the other and a requirement from geoconservationists and the scientific community for some form of objective appraisal of these alternatives is necessary. Consequently in the second part of this paper we evaluate these alternative approaches and the role they can play in a ‘record and digitally rescue’ conservation strategy. Using modern footprint data, digital models created via optical laser scanning are compared to those generated by state-of-the-art photogrammetry. Both methods give comparable although subtly different results. This data is evaluated alongside a review of field deployment issues to provide guidance to the community with respect to the factors which need to be considered in digital conservation of human/hominin footprints.

Dinosaur tracks from the Langenberg Quarry (Late Jurassic, Germany) reconstructed with historical photogrammetry: Evidence for large theropods soon after insular dwarfism

“…This holds true especially for footprints, which are often left in situ because an excavation is not desirable or realizable, and therefore are exposed to weathering (Bennett et al, 2013). When a specimen is removed from its stratigraphical and paleobiological context during excavation, the loss of important information is a likely risk, especially when excavations are insufficiently documented (i.e., emergency excavations).…”

Shape variability in tridactyl dinosaur footprints: the significance of size and function

“…when single footprints are meaningful only in their spatial context) or impracticable (Bennett et al . ). Scientific access to specimens remaining in the field can be complicated given the remoteness of many sites and the degradation over time due to weathering.…”

Identification of the Anteroposterior and Mediolateral Position of Lion Paws and Tracks Using 3D Geometric Morphometrics

“…The scale bar enabled scaling of the 3D models. Close-range digital photogrammetry applied to hominid and human tracks showed comparable results to optical laser scanning (Vi900 KonicaMinolta) (Bennett, Falkingham, Morse, Bates & Crompton, 2013). Accuracy tests on the Vi900 Konica-Minolta yielded an accuracy of 0.19 mm on x-plane, 0.14 mm on y-plane and 0.10 mm on z-plane (Keating, Knox, Bibb & Zhurov, 2008).…”