“…[13,14] In this regard, some researchers have made efforts to searchf or low-cost candidates such as bismuth metal to replacee xpensive precious metal catalysts (Pt, Au, Ir,P d, Ru). [11,[15][16][17][18][19] Additionally,s ome low-costa nd chemically stable metal oxides, such as Mn 3 O 4 , PbO 2 ,N b 2 O 5 ,C eO 2 and WO 3 have also proven to be effective in facilitating vanadiumr edox reactions, but the particles ize, amount and distribution of suchc atalysts on the carbon electrode all seem to be critical to the electrode performance, most likely owing to their poor electronicc onductivity. [12,[20][21][22][23] Moreover,the catalystparticles are easily peeled off the carbon surfaces over time, hindering the long-term cyclic performance of the cell.T herefore, recent investigationso ni nsitu nitrogen doping or attaching oxygen functional groups are becoming more attractive.…”