Prefrontal Cortex Oxygenation During Endurance Performance: A Systematic Review of Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy Studies

Abstract

Introduction: A myriad of factors underlie pacing-/exhaustion-decisions that are made during whole-body endurance performance. The prefrontal cortex (PFC) is a brain region that is crucial for decision-making, planning, and attention. PFC oxygenation seems to be a mediating factor of performance decisions during endurance performance. Nowadays, there is no general overview summarizing the current knowledge on how PFC oxygenation evolves during whole-body endurance performance and whether this is a determining factor.Methods: Three electronic databases were searched for studies related to the assessment of PFC oxygenation, through near-IR spectroscopy (NIRS), during endurance exercise. To express PFC oxygenation, oxygenated (HbO2) and deoxygenated hemoglobin (HHb) concentrations were the primary outcome measures.Results: Twenty-eight articles were included. Ten articles focused on assessing prefrontal oxygenation through a maximal incremental test (MIT) and 18 focused on using endurance tasks at workloads ranging from low intensity to supramaximal intensity. In four MIT studies measuring HbO2, an increase of HbO2 was noticed at the respiratory compensation point (RCP), after which it decreased. HbO2 reached a steady state in the four studies and increased in one study until exhaustion. All studies found a decrease or steady state in HHb from the start until RCP and an increase to exhaustion. In regard to (non-incremental) endurance tasks, a general increase in PFC oxygenation was found while achieving a steady state at vigorous intensities. PCF deoxygenation was evident for near-to-maximal intensities at which an increase in oxygenation and the maintenance of a steady state could not be retained.Discussion/Conclusion: MIT studies show the presence of a cerebral oxygenation threshold (ThCox) at RCP. PFC oxygenation increases until the RCP threshold, thereafter, a steady state is reached and HbO2 declines. This study shows that the results obtained from MIT are transferable to non-incremental endurance exercise. HbO2 increases during low-intensity and moderate-intensity until vigorous-intensity exercise, and it reaches a steady state in vigorous-intensity exercise. Furthermore, ThCox can be found between vigorous and near-maximal intensities. During endurance exercise at near-maximal intensities, PFC oxygenation increases until the value exceeding this threshold, resulting in a decrease in PFC oxygenation. Future research should aim at maintaining and improving PFC oxygenation to help in improving endurance performance and to examine whether PFC oxygenation has a role in other performance-limiting factors.

Mental Fatigue-Associated Decrease in Table Tennis Performance: Is There an Electrophysiological Signature?

“…Moreover, within θ power, the Fz, F3 and F4 electrodes were implicated in a decrease in energy. These electrodes are located near the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, further adding to the literature implicating this region in MF and its effects [ 25 , 58 ].…”

The Physiological Nature of Mental Fatigue: Current Knowledge and Future Avenues for Sport Science

“…The prefrontal cortex has been implicated as an important area in exercise decision making, for example, the decision to stop exercising because of an increase in effort. 7 Moreover, adenosine may affect motivation during specific tasks, as it can inhibit the release of dopamine and modify the affinity of dopamine receptors. 6 Although this is a promising hypothesis, direct evidence should be gathered to confirm it.…”

Estimation of Cerebral Hemodynamics and Oxygenation During Various Intensities of Rowing Exercise: An NIRS Study

“…Because the medial PFC is involved in both executive control and the emotional salience network in conjunction with many other brain regions, such as the insular and anterior cingulate cortex, oxygenation in the PFC would be a surrogate for observing interoception caused by rowing exercise ( Craig, 2009 ). Additionally, the PFC has been explored in NIRS studies that investigated the underlying mechanism of the pacing strategy related to an experimental model of time-to-exhaustion ( De Wachter et al, 2021 ). From the perspective of the regulation of endurance exercise in the brain, the PFC has a key role in brain regions such as the anterior cingulate cortex and premotor area cortex, which integrate afferent and efferent information mandatory for executive function for endurance exercise ( Robertson and Marino, 2016 ).…”

“…Previous studies have investigated the association between fatigue or exhaustion induced by maximal-intensity rowing exercise by measuring oxygenation of the prefrontal cortex (PFC) using near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) and the cerebral metabolic ratio, which is the oxygen-to-glucose index determined by arterial-to-internal jugular venous differences in the entire brain ( Secher et al, 2008 ; Volianitis et al, 2020 ). Because of its practical utility, a large number of studies focused on oxygenation changes in the PFC during exercise ( Herold et al, 2018 ; De Wachter et al, 2021 ). Furthermore, several studies using NIRS have investigated oxygenation in the PFC during rowing exercise ( Nielsen et al, 1999 , 2001 ; Faull et al, 2015 ).…”