Predictors of Non-Response to a Questionnaire Survey of a Volunteer Twin Panel: Findings from the Australian 1989 Twin Cohort

Abstract

Questionnaire surveys, while more economical, typically achieve poorer response rates than interview surveys. We used data from a national volunteer cohort of young adult twins, who were scheduled for assessment by questionnaire in 1989 and by interview in 1996-2000, to identify predictors of questionnaire non-response. Out of a total of 8536 twins, 5058 completed the questionnaire survey (59% response rate), and 6255 completed a telephone interview survey conducted a decade later (73% response rate). Multinomial logit models were fitted to the interview data to identify socioeconomic, psychiatric and health behavior correlates of non-response in the earlier questionnaire survey. Male gender, education below University level, and being a dizygotic rather than monozygotic twin, all predicted reduced likelihood of participating in the questionnaire survey. Associations between questionnaire response status and psychiatric history and health behavior variables were modest, with history of alcohol dependence and childhood conduct disorder predicting decreased probability of returning a questionnaire, and history of smoking and heavy drinking more weakly associated with non-response. Body-mass index showed no association with questionnaire non-response. Despite a poor response rate to the self-report questionnaire survey, we found only limited sampling biases for most variables. While not appropriate for studies where socioeconomic variables are critical, it appears that survey by questionnaire, with questionnaire administration by telephone to non-responders, will represent a viable strategy for gene-mapping studies requiring that large numbers of relatives be screened.

Costs and effectiveness of a brief MRI examination of patients with acute knee injury

“…In many studies the response rate to mailed questionnaires is about 60-65% [27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34]. In our study the response rate of patients that underwent both radiography and MRI was within that range, but the response rate of patients that only underwent radiography was lower, most likely because they were disappointed not to get an extra MRI examination during randomization and less willing to fill in the questionnaires.…”

Childhood sexual abuse and risks for licit and illicit drug-related outcomes: a twin study

“…The young adult cohort of the Australian Twin Register is a volunteer panel composed of twins born 1964-1971(Heath et al 2001Nelson et al 2002;Lynskey et al 2002Lynskey et al , 2003Knopik et al 2004). Nearly all were registered by parents between 1980 and 1982 in response to approaches through school systems or mass media.…”

Defining nicotine dependence for genetic research: evidence from Australian twins

“…Twins either volunteered themselves or were volunteered by their parents. This twin cohort was first targeted for assessment in 1989-1992 (' 1989 cohort ') by mailed questionnaire survey (Gillespie et al 2000 ;Heath et al 2001). Between 1996 and 2000, the 1989 cohort was interviewed by telephone using a structured diagnostic assessment for DSM-IV alcohol dependence, nicotine dependence, major depression, panic disorder, and childhood conduct disorder (APA, 1994) as well as non-diagnostic sections for social anxiety, suicidality, a screening for bipolar disorder, and a history of the consumption of alcohol, cigarettes and other forms of tobacco, and illicit drugs.…”