“…Typical of the traditional view, earlier work has reported that they have rather weak effects (except for the long-recognized effects of landscape heterogeneity in terms of topography; e.g., Kerr & Packer, 1997;Nichols, Killingbeck, & August, 1998;Reino et al, 2018;Thuiller, Araujo, & Lavorel, 2004;White & Miller, 1988). However, recent studies suggested that they have strong power that cannot be neglected, shaping macro-scale biodiversity patterns in areas with strong anthropogenic landscape modifications (Martins, Proença, & Pereira, 2014;Ramesh, Kalle, & Downs, 2016;Xu et al, 2014). To ascertain whether landscape attributes are indeed the "unusual suspect" (a metaphor used by Martins et al, 2014), we need to understand what underlies these two contradictory lines of evidence.…”