Predictors of healthcare professionals’ attitudes towards family involvement in safety-relevant behaviours: a cross-sectional factorial survey study

Abstract

ObjectivesTo investigate predictors of healthcare professionals’ (HCPs) attitudes towards family involvement in safety-relevant behaviours.DesignA cross-sectional fractional factorial survey that assessed HCPs’ attitudes towards family involvement in two error scenarios relating to hand hygiene and medication safety. Each survey comprised two randomised vignettes that described the potential error, how the family member communicated with the HCP about the error and how the HCP responded to the family member’s question.Setting5 teaching hospitals in London, the Midlands and York. HCPs were approached on a range of medical and surgical wards.Participants160 HCPs (73 doctors; 87 nurses) aged between 21 and 65 years (mean 37) 102 were female.Outcome measuresHCP approval of family member’s behaviour; HCP reaction to the family member; anticipated effects on the family member–HCP relationship; HCP support for being questioned about hand hygiene/medication; affective rating responses.ResultsHCPs supported family member's intervening (88%) but only 41% agreed this would have positive effects on the family member/HCP relationship. Across vignettes and error scenarios the strongest predictors of attitudes were how the HCP (in the scenario) responded to the family member and whether an error actually occurred. Doctors (vs nurses) provided systematically more positive affective ratings to the vignettes.ConclusionsImportant predictors of HCPs’ attitudes towards family members’ involvement in patient safety have been highlighted. In particular, a discouraging response from HCP’s decreased support for family members being involved and had strong perceived negative effects on the family member/HCP relationship.

Use of a patient empowerment tool for hand hygiene

“…Davis demonstrated that only 41% of providers felt that family member involvement would have a positive effect on the family member-provider relationship. 13 Similarly, Kim found that only 26% of physicians and 31% of nurses supported patient participation. 14 In Julian’s survey of healthcare providers, the major reasons providers did not support patient empowerment were providers did not feel it was the patient’s responsibility, the patient may not see that the provider previously cleansed their hands, and reminders from the patient were embarrassing or inappropriate.…”

“…Healthcare workers have expressed concern that patient empowerment will have a negative impact on the patient-physician relationship. 13, 14 …”

Family involvement in emergency department discharge education for older people

“…Studies have tried to cover family involvement from the perspectives of healthcare professionals (HCPs; Davis et al . ), patients (Lin et al . ) and family members (e.g.…”

Family Experiences and Perspectives on Infection Prevention in Pediatric Long-Term Care

“…More forethought considering their feedback should be put into planning educational activities and materials. As clinicians responsible for patient and family education, nurses should encourage and empower family members to play significant roles in optimizing IP efforts (Davis, Savvopoulou, Shergill, Shergill, & Schwappach, 2014). …”