Predicting the clinical performance of dental students with a manual dexterity test

Abstract

Dentists must be skilled when using dental mirrors. Working with mirrors requires spatial perception, bimanual coordination, perceptual learning and fine motor skills. Many studies have attempted to determine the predictors of manual skills among pre-clinical students, but consensus has yet to be reached. We hypothesized that valid and reliable occupational therapy test performance regarding indirect vision would differ between dental students and junior dentists and would explain the variance in manual skill performance in pre-clinical courses. To test this hypothesis, we applied the Purdue Pegboard test and O’Connor Tweezer Dexterity test under different conditions of direct and indirect vision. We administered these tests to students in phantom-head academic courses in 2015 and 2016 and to junior dentists. Students performed the tests at three time points: before phantom training (T0), at the end of the training (T1) and in the middle of the following year of study (T2). Dentists performed the same tests twice at 1st and 2nd trials one week apart. The results showed that indirect tasks were significantly more difficult to perform for both groups. These dexterity tests were sensitive enough to detect students’ improvement after phantom training. The dentists’ performances were significantly better than those of students at T0, specifically with regard to the use of tweezers under direct and indirect vision (the O’Connor test). A regression analysis showed that students’ manual grades obtained at the beginning of the phantom course, their performance on the Purdue test using both hands, and their performance on the O’Connor test under indirect vision predicted phantom course success in 80% of cases. The O’Connor test under indirect vision is the most informative means of monitoring and predicting the manual skills required in the pre-clinical year of dentistry studies.

“I am a lefty in a right‐handed world”: Qualitative analysis of clinical learning experience of left‐handed undergraduate dental students

“…scale. 4,5 Delivery of successful dental treatment depends upon multiple factors that include position and anatomy of the tooth, selection of proper instrument, correct angulation of the instrument and manual skills. It also involves the proper position of the patient and operator.…”

The effect of indirect vision skills on head and shoulder posture amongst Korean dental hygienists

“…In previous studies, 7-9 dental hygienists reported experiencing musculoskeletal discomfort, which is a significant burden to them, in the five regions examined in the studies, as well as in the wrists/hands. Finally, as in a previous study, 16 the Despite these limitations, the present study had several strengths. It quantitatively assessed the posture of the head and shoulders, factors that contribute to the onset and perpetuation of WMSD, to evaluate the musculoskeletal status of clinical dental hygienists.…”

“…25 To evaluate indirect vision skills, the O'Connor tweezer test (Lafayette Instrument) was conducted under indirect vision using a mirror. 16 The tool consisted of a board with 25 holes, 100 small metal pins and tweezers. A blackboard shield was placed to prevent participants from directly viewing the board, and a mirror was in-…”

Looking at Male Nurse Discrimination Among Nursing Students With O’connor’s Finger Dexterity Test: Future of Gender Discrimination

“…11 The O'Connor's finger dexterity test was also safely used in dentistry students to evaluate fine motor skills and hand-eye coordination. 12,13 This test is also used in clinical areas. It was used in studies based on physiotherapy.…”