Precarious employment among South Korean women: Is inequality changing with time?

Abstract

Theories of precarious employment based on the constructs of job quality and job stability have highlighted the issue of transitions, linked to gender and age, from long-duration employment in bad-quality jobs, into good-quality stable employment. This article uses Markov chain analysis to study the labour market transitions of South Korean women in different age groups. It shows the importance of differentiating the effects of contemporary labour market conditions, shaped by the forces of the moment, from conditions created by the institutional legacy of the past. Women’s traditional position in the labour market has resulted in age-linked gendered precariousness, while the conditions of the moment are generating a tendency towards less precarious employment. Transition matrices are developed for types of precarious employment defined by the combination of job stability and job quality, taking into account duration by age group, time period, and covariates. These matrices yield distributions of asymptotic prevalence, reflecting labour market conditions of the moment. The forces of the moment favour the predominance of stable good-quality employment, whereas observed prevalence at a given date is characterised by the polarisation of the labour market between stable good-quality and unstable bad-quality employment. Asymptotic prevalence reveals a steady increase in stable but bad-quality employment. Older women are observed mostly in unstable bad-quality employment, but labour market conditions are tending to attenuate this age cleavage over time, as the conditions of the moment are reducing the proportions of older women in stable bad-quality and unstable good-quality employment. The conclusion is an age-based polarisation, in which older women are faring badly, but where possibilities are now opening up to younger South Korean women, reflected in the sharp break between the situation inherited from the past and the conditions of the moment. But possibilities for younger women will be realised only through a reinforcement of government policies to support career breaks and work–family balance through decent part-time jobs. JEL Codes: J08, J28, J44

Family formation trends and patterns of women's work trajectories in South Korea: determinants and cohort differences

“…It is often argued that 'flexible' non-standard employment can facilitate not only mothers' return to the labour market, but also the reconciliation of work and family responsibilities (Laß & Wooden, 2020;Morris & Vekker, 2001;Wooden & Warren, 2004). However, while these benefits of flexible employment are highlighted in other country contexts, in Korea non-regular jobs are often of low quality due to low pay and limited access to social benefits (Bonneuil & Kim, 2017;Y. Kim, 2015).…”

“…For Korean mothers', non-regular jobs are oftentimes the only means to reenter the labour market after they have interrupted their employment for childbirth and want to return to work when their children grow older (Bonneuil & Kim, 2017). Korean mothers' career interruptions are also shown to increase their chance to be self-employed or work as an unpaid family worker (Kim, 2016;Sung, 2002).…”

Understanding women’s empowerment in post-Covid Korea: A historical analysis

“…As a consequence, labour force participation among married women, while undergoing moderate growth, remained at much lower levels compared to other population groups (Lee and Song, 2018). However, there is also evidence suggesting that women in general, and young women in particular, are more career-oriented than their predecessors and increasingly in wellpaid stable employment and delaying or avoiding marriage and/or childbirth (Bonneuil and Kim, 2017;Cho and Bang, 2005;Lee and Kwon, 2015;Ma, 2016). Between 2008 and 2018, the employment rate of women aged between 30-34 increased by 10.6 percentage points (from 51.9% to 62.5%), marking the biggest growth among all age groups (Statistics Korea, 2019).…”

Precariousness on the Swedish labour market: A theoretical and empirical account

“…Self-employed workers enable employers to cut expenses related to social costs and so-called unproductive time, whereby the self-employed worker often remains dependent on a small number of outsourcers or clients (Moore and Newsome, 2018). Recent developments on contemporary labour markets, such as deregulation of labour laws and the growth of the so-called gig economy, can be more or less regarded as institutionalised forms of widespread economic disadvantage and employment insecurity (Bonneuil and Kim, 2017; Chan, 2013; Judzik et al, 2016). Clearly overlapping with precarious employment, the concept of ‘ precarious work’ may be used to refer to the actual job performed and the fact that the worker bears the risks associated to this activity (Hewison and Kalleberg, 2013).…”