Pre‐medical majors in the humanities and social sciences: impact on communication skills and specialty choice

Abstract

Context Medical school admissions committees use a variety of criteria to determine which candidates to admit to their programmes. Effective communication is increasingly considered a key requisite to the practice of effective medicine. Medical students with pre‐medical backgrounds in the humanities and social sciences may be more likely to acquire skills relevant to patient‐centred communication, either prior to or during medical school. Objectives The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between pre‐medical backgrounds in the humanities and social sciences and outcomes in medical school, including in communication and interpersonal skills (CIS), licensure examination results and postgraduate specialty choice (primary care versus non‐primary care specialties). Methods The American Medical College Application Service database was used to identify pre‐medical college majors, demographic characteristics, Medical College Admission Test scores and college grade point averages for medical students at a large, midwestern medical school. Data were obtained for 465 medical students across three cohorts (classes of 2014–2016). Correlation and regression analyses were used to examine relationships between pre‐medical background, performance on graduation competency examination standardised patient encounter CIS scores and on United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) Step 1 and Step 2 Clinical Knowledge scores, and postgraduate specialty choice. Results Graduating medical students with pre‐medical humanities or social sciences majors performed significantly better in terms of CIS than those with natural science majors (Cohen's d = 0.28, p = 0.011). There were no significant associations between pre‐medical majors and USMLE Step 1 and Step 2 Clinical Knowledge scores or postgraduate specialty choice. Conclusions These results suggest that considering humanistic factors as part of admissions criteria may promote the selection and training of physicians with good communication skills.

Personality, Resilience, and Calling in Students Undertaking a Medical Degree Across Two Continents: Disparate Pathways to the Healing Profession

“…A 2019 study showed that medical students with degrees in humanities or social science perform significantly better in interpersonal skills and communication compared to medical students with science degrees. 42 Shacklady et al found that students entering medicine just a few years older than age 21 years experienced a better transition from preclinical to clinical learning, 43 suggesting that life experience and social factors are influential at this age.…”

Beyond empathy: a qualitative exploration of arts and humanities in pre-professional (baccalaureate) health education

“…Doukas et al (2015) for example, call for a more focused attention to medical school's admission process that encompasses "pre-professional readiness" of ethics and humanities, which might encourage "premedical learners to appreciate exposure to philosophy, anthropology, sociology, and psychology as valuable preparation toward medical education, including the groundwork of critical thinking skill building" (p. 739). Simultaneously, recent research has begun to explore how interdisciplinary training at the baccalaureate level impacts pre-professional students' understanding of health (Schwartz et al 2009;Crawford et al 2015;Baker et al 2017;Barron 2017;Berry and Lamb 2017;Charise 2017;Hirshfield et al 2019;Jones et al 2019;Wald et al 2019).…”

The Resurgence of Medical Education in Sociology: A Return to Our Roots and an Agenda for the Future

“…However, there is also evidence that undergraduate education matters significantly, raising questions about the typical pipeline for medical school admissions from STEM fields. Hirshfield, Yudkowsky, and Park (2019) found that medical students who majored in humanities or social science scored higher in communication skills exams, and Olsen and Gebremariam (2020) found that humanities and interpretive social sciences majors entered and left medical school with higher empathy than their STEM peers. All of these trends demonstrate challenges in the values of the profession as well as in the context of medical work.…”