Practitioners and Saints: Medical Men in Canonization Processes in the Thirteenth to Fifteenth Centuries

Abstract

This article shows that recourse to expert medical judgement for authenticating miracles has medieval roots which lead to the thirteenth century. It provides a survey of those cases in the printed versions of canonization processes from c. 1200 to c. 1500 where medical men actively appeared as witnesses. It shows how, from the second half of the thirteenth century, many canonization processes (overwhelmingly in southern Europe) included at least one medical man who witnessed or gave expert testimony as a supplier of medicine. The physicians who appeared as expert witnesses were expected to rule out the possibility that there was a natural explanation for the wonderous cure. To acquire medical confirmation that a certain cure was miraculous seemed highly desirable to those wishing to substantiate claims of sanctity. Physician witnesses were often called upon to evaluate cases of which they had personal knowledge because of the medical know-how they possessed: however, medical science was not considered so universal that any physician could review the case (as is theoretically the case today in the medical council at the Vatican). Thus, to the therapeutic function of physicians and surgeons in southern Europe from the second half of the thirteenth century, a hitherto neglected duty should be added: whenever necessary, the community as well as the local ecclesiastical authorities expected the suppliers of medical services to contribute to the formal recognition of an apparent saint.

Why Gerontologists Should Care About Empirical Research on Religion and Health: Transdisciplinary Perspectives

“…Religion was the primary macrolevel institution, dictating the values, norms, and, often, political structures and policies of the society (Bruce, 1997). Medicine itself was based in religious institutions in the premodern world (Ziegler, 1999). Industrialization, urbanization, and secularization transformed the status and power of religion and family.…”

Miracles in the waiting room of modernity: The canonisation of Dun Ġorġ of Malta

“…Miracles were very much a part of what constituted the fama sanctitatis (Reputation of Sanctity) in the middle ages. In the canonisation proceedings of Louis of Toulouse and in the case of Urban V (1376/7), for example, there is a collection of more than 200 miracles (Ziegler 1999). By the thirteenth century, with the centralisation of the canonisation process, miracles had become the subject of official examination (Goodich 1983: 170).…”

“…It is important, however, to emphasise that such transformations did not occur overnight. Indeed, the proceedings of canonisation trials, from at least the thirteenth century, regularly featured a medicus (medical man) as an expert witness (Ziegler 1999). However, we should also note that in the hagiographical literature of the early middle ages, the medicus appears as a foil to the superior and supernatural power of the saints (Flint 1989: 135).…”

Medical 'Emplotment' and Plotting Medicine: Health and Disease in Late Medieval Portuguese Chronicles

“…22Flint 1989; Mattoso 1993; Ziegler 1999; Pilsworth 2000; McCleery in Cooper and Gregory (eds) 2005.…”