Practice Variation Research in Degenerative Lumbar Disc Surgery: A Literature Review on Design Characteristics and Outcomes

Abstract

Study Design Literature review. Objective To describe whether practice variation studies on surgery in patients with lumbar degenerative disc disease used adequate study methodology to identify unwarranted variation, and to inform quality improvement in clinical practice. Secondary aim was to describe whether variation changed over time. Methods Literature databases were searched up to May 4th, 2021. To define whether study design was appropriate to identify unwarranted variation, we extracted data on level of aggregation, study population, and case-mix correction. To define whether studies were appropriate to achieve quality improvement, data were extracted on outcomes, explanatory variables, description of scientific basis, and given recommendations. Spearman’s rho was used to determine the association between the Extreme Quotient (EQ) and year of publication. Results We identified 34 articles published between 1990 and 2020. Twenty-six articles (76%) defined the diagnosis. Prior surgery cases were excluded or adjusted for in 5 articles (15%). Twenty-three articles (68%) adjusted for case-mix. Variation in outcomes was analyzed in 7 articles (21%). Fourteen articles (41%) identified explanatory variables. Twenty-six articles (76%) described the evidence on effectiveness. Recommendations for clinical practice were given in 9 articles (26%). Extreme Quotients ranged between 1-fold and 15-fold variation and did not show a significant change over time (rho= −.33, P= .09). Conclusions Practice variation research on surgery in patients with degenerative disc disease showed important limitations to identify unwarranted variation and to achieve quality improvement by public reporting. Despite the availability of new evidence, we could not observe a significant decrease in variation over time.

Practice variation in surgical treatment for lumbar degenerative disc disease: exploring regional and hospital factors influencing surgical rates

“…Hence, practice variation might partly be driven by differences in physicians’ beliefs about the effectiveness of the treatment. Previous studies have reported substantial regional variation in surgical rates for Lumbar Radicular Syndrome (LRS) caused by degenerative disc disease (DDD) within and between regions and countries 2 .…”

Practice Variation in Surgical Treatment for Lumbar Degenerative Disc Disease: Exploring Regional and Hospital Factors Influencing Surgical Rates

“…Hence, practice variation might partly be driven by differences in physicians' beliefs about the effectiveness of the treatment. Previous studies have reported substantial regional variation in surgical rates for Lumbar Radicular Syndrome (LRS) caused by degenerative disc disease (DDD) within and between regions and countries 2 . LRS, resulting from degenerative disc disease, can be attributed to a herniated disc, spinal stenosis, or spondylolisthesis.…”