The Covid-19 pandemic necessitated an abrupt shift to emergency remote teaching and learning (ERT&L) in higher education institutions across the globe. In this shift, assessment and feedback, widely regarded as the heart of student learning experiences and a gauge of quality teaching pre Covid-19, became a major source of discontent and challenge for students and staff. In this paper, we present our reflections of observed and reported practices of assessment by staff and students, from the vantage point of our roles as facilitators of various professional development initiatives within our institution. We suggest that the challenges experienced during ERT&L reveal the entrenched view of assessment as gatekeeping and conceptions of quality as exceptional. We further contend that assessment strategies based on such a view during ERT&L may have further marginalized and disadvantaged students faced with digital/technological, economic, and socio-cultural access issues. However, we also highlight that despite the challenges for students and staff, the experience may have broadened lecturers’ views of their role in addressing the ongoing social justice challenges of access, and the power of sustainable assessment practices to unsettle inequalities within higher education.