Power Relationship in the Governance of Regional Tourism Organizations in Brazil

Abstract

Objective: The development of tourism is one the main objectives of managers seeking a greater competitive advantage for destinations. To achieve this objective, the political-institutional structure related to public and private organizations involved in the Brazilian scenario of tourism activities deliberately operate in the format of Regional Tourism Organizations—RTOs, which started in 2004. In this context, the aim of this study arose, which is to analyze the power relations of Regional Tourism Organizations of tourist regions. Design/Methodology: This research adopted a qualitative and quantitative approach, with data collection through documents, laws, reports and information about the RTOs and questionnaires in forms applied to 27 representatives of the public sector, 14 representatives of private sector and six representatives of the third sector, from a total population of 89 active members of the Regional Tourism Organizations: Costa Verde e Mar (state of Santa Catarina), Hortênsias (state of Rio Grande do Sul), and Costa das Dunas (state of Rio Grande do Norte). During the application of the forms, interviews were carried out, totaling 47 interviews with members of the RTOs. Quantitative analyses were generated by mean, mode, absolute and relative frequencies, multiple responses and dispersion graph, with the use of descriptive analyses. The qualitative analyses involving documents were descriptive, and those involving oral information were carried out using analysis of content of Bardin (1977). The different methods that were used in an interrelated manner and helped in the analysis of the data coming from the application of forms (quantitative), official documents (laws/decrees, regulations and statutes), and interviews with actors of the regional tourism organizations (qualitative), enabled the measurement of the effectiveness of the process of management of RTOs in relation to the dimension Power Relationship and the variables analyzed Representativeness, Harmony, Trust and Decision-Making Power. Results: As a result, it was seen that the regional tourism organizations of the tourist regions operate in an effective manner in the public or private sectors and that they involve the management of shared practices by the regional tourism organizations in the destinations studied in terms of representativeness, harmony, trust and decision-making power. Novelty/Value: This research theoretically deepened for the academy the theme of regional governance and power relationship between public and private actors in tourism who are important for the competitive performance of a tourist destination. It also analyzes how the management and governance of regional tourism organizations behaves in terms of power relationships.

Human resources management as a factor determining the organizational effectiveness of DMOs: a case study of RTOs in Poland

“…The research findings imply that RTOs are a “good platform” for the development of a regional knowledge-based tourism economy (Conceição et al , 2019; Nawrocka, 2008). Furthermore, they are effective providers of social capital in the tourism economy (Sierocińska, 2011).…”

Developing a Competitive and Sustainable Destination of the Future: Clusters and Predictors of Successful National-Level Destination Governance across Destination Life-Cycle

“…Successful destination governance needs to include common goals, a balanced power between the actors and co-evolutionary adaptations [68][69][70][71]. The phenomena related to poor governance mostly include hierarchical structures, lack of inclusion trust and perceived justice from actors [70,72], while the new and emerging theme in destination governance are public-private partnerships [73,74].…”

Dynamics of protest and participation in the governance of tourism in Barcelona: a strategic action field perspective

“…Governance of tourism can be understood as a regionally and locally embedded relationship between stakeholders "who are engaged in planning, managing and controlling the tourism activity" (Oliveira, 2014, in Conceição et al, 2019. Governance of tourism studies usually assume implicitly that the relationship between these stakeholdersincluding the municipal government, but also various private interest groups and civil society organisationsare based on trust and involves collaboration and co-operation (Damayanti et al, 2019;Gonz alez-Morales et al, 2016).…”

“…As such, protests taking place 'outside' formal governance mechanisms and channels have been researched only marginally, although academic interest does seem to be gaining momentum (C ocola-Gant & Pardo, 2017;Milano et al, 2019;Novy & Colomb, 2017;Sequera & Nofre, 2019). Secondly, governance of tourism studies focus mainly on the national level (Conceição et al, 2019;Scott & Marzano, 2015) or on smaller settlements at the local levelincluding towns and villages (Beaumont & Dredge, 2010, Sawatsuk et al, 2018, natural and coastal areas (Presenza et al, 2013;Qian et al, 2016) and rural areas in developing countries (Adiyia et al, 2015) as tourism destinations. As such, there is a relative lack of attention for large and mature urban tourism destinationsoften with more complex institutional bodies and a wider variety of stakeholders involved in tourism governance.…”