Power Law versus Exponential State Transition Dynamics: Application to Sleep-Wake Architecture

Abstract

BackgroundDespite the common experience that interrupted sleep has a negative impact on waking function, the features of human sleep-wake architecture that best distinguish sleep continuity versus fragmentation remain elusive. In this regard, there is growing interest in characterizing sleep architecture using models of the temporal dynamics of sleep-wake stage transitions. In humans and other mammals, the state transitions defining sleep and wake bout durations have been described with exponential and power law models, respectively. However, sleep-wake stage distributions are often complex, and distinguishing between exponential and power law processes is not always straightforward. Although mono-exponential distributions are distinct from power law distributions, multi-exponential distributions may in fact resemble power laws by appearing linear on a log-log plot.Methodology/Principal FindingsTo characterize the parameters that may allow these distributions to mimic one another, we systematically fitted multi-exponential-generated distributions with a power law model, and power law-generated distributions with multi-exponential models. We used the Kolmogorov-Smirnov method to investigate goodness of fit for the “incorrect” model over a range of parameters. The “zone of mimicry” of parameters that increased the risk of mistakenly accepting power law fitting resembled empiric time constants obtained in human sleep and wake bout distributions.Conclusions/SignificanceRecognizing this uncertainty in model distinction impacts interpretation of transition dynamics (self-organizing versus probabilistic), and the generation of predictive models for clinical classification of normal and pathological sleep architecture.

Dissecting functional connectivity of neuronal microcircuits: experimental and theoretical insights

“…Missing connections between nearest neighbors k=4 c =1/6 data interpretation [35]. Accurate fitting and validation of power law distributions is an active area of investigation in statistics.…”

“…It is interesting to point out that studies using model systems, such as zebrafish [68], Caenorhabditis elegans [35,69] and Drosophila [70], have started using advanced data mining and analyses that are currently far ahead of mammalian brain studies. The reason for this is probably due to the fact that access to entire and large networks can be achieved in the case of these model organisms because of their small sizes and relative architectural simplicity, while at the same time offering a rich behavioral repertoire [68][69][70][71][72].…”

Population assessment of tropical tuna based on their associative behavior around floating objects

“…In some cases, power-law models also performed well. The distinction between multiple exponentials and power laws is not always straightforward, particularly for reduced number of points52. We therefore adopted the principle of parsimony and considered the simplest model that fitted well the experimental curves, thus choosing the exponentials models that best fitted the data.…”

Statistics for Sleep and Biological Rhythms Research

“…Even when sample sizes are large, understanding the distribution may not be straightforward. For example, we showed that human sleep stage bout length distributions previously attributed to power-law equations could be equally well described by the sum of 2–3 exponential functions (Chu-Shore et al, 2010). …”