Potestas and the language of power: Conceptualising an approach to Power and Discernment politeness in ancient languages

Abstract

The concept of "Discernment politeness" stems from research undertaken in the 1980s on the Japanese phenomenon of wakimae. Since the earliest work on the phenomenon by Hill et al. (1986) and Ide (1989Ide ( , 1992, many scholars have looked to further explore Discernment across cultures (i.e. Kádár and Mills 2013;Kádár and Paternoster 2015;Ridealgh and Jucker 2019). Fundamentally, Discernment has been approached as expected (and quasi-mandatory) behavioural norms used by subordinates towards their superiors within a communicative act, dictated by the socio-cultural context of the interaction (Ridealgh and Jucker 2019). What becomes apparent, when studying ancient languages, is that due to the hierarchical nature of remote societies, Discernment includes a complementary dimension, an opposing phenomenon to deference, equally visible in interpersonal interactions, which has its foundation within the Power variable. This paper explores this opposing phenomenon (i.e. expected or permitted language used by superiors to their subordinates as a manifestation of their Power), which we call "Potestas", within the context of Late Egyptian and Old Latin, in order to highlight the phenomenon, its forms of expression in these two languages, the gaps in regards to the Power variable within traditional politeness approaches, and its relationship with (Im)politeness Research.

Apology Strategy in Senior High School Students of North Aceh Dialect

“…Apology strategies based on Age Group showed that there were 30 respondents aged 16-17 years who tended to be direct and 10 respondents aged +-15 years tended to be indirect in the apology strategy. The age factor is one of many other factors that determine a person's language politeness (Ridealgh & Gómez, 2020;Wang et al, 2023). Age is a determining factor of universally applicable human language politeness.…”

Portrait of students’ language politeness in elementary school

“…Language speakers can express and interpret politeness according to their behavior indeed [11]. Language politeness is a very interesting issue to study because it is hierarchical in uncovering phenomena between speakers and speech partners who communicate throughout life [12]. In addition, politeness in language can create togetherness between educators and students, build respectful behavior for students, and create collaborative interactions between educators and students [13].…”