Background: This study was conducted to confirm the reliability of an in vitro mechanically induced hemolysis test (ISO 10993-4:2017), which is essential for ensuring the safety of blood pumps. Methods: For appropriate anticoagulant selection, porcine blood was prepared in anticoagulant citrate dextrose solution A (ACD-A), heparin, and citrate phosphate dextrose adenine (CPDA-1), respectively, according to the ASTM F1830 standard. Anticoagulant-treated porcine and bovine blood were circulated in a mock circulatory loop (MCL) for 6 h to observe the rate of plasma-free hemoglobin (pfHb) and RBCs with morphological integrity. Results: A morphological loss of red blood cells (RBCs) was observed over time. While there were differences in morphological loss depending on the anticoagulant, no consistent trend could be identified. The pfHb concentration was significantly higher in bovine than in porcine blood. Conversely, the number of RBCs with morphological integrity decreased over time in both, but the ratio of RBCs with morphological integrity was similar across all timepoints. Conclusions: The percentage of RBCs with morphological integrity can be used as a reliable indicator for the interpretation of mechanically induced hemolysis results in different blood types. Furthermore, the reliability of the in vitro mechanically induced hemolysis test (ISO 10993-4:2017) was assessed.