Postpartum maternal death associated with undiagnosed Hodgkin's lymphoma

Abstract

The authors describe the case of a 28-year-old patient who died from an extensive intracerebral haemorrhage due to disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) which occurred a few days after delivery. Access to an emergency department of gynaecology on three separate occasions in the three days preceding hospitalization made judicial evaluation of the case necessary. The case was studied with a methodological approach based on the following steps: (1) examination of clinical records; (2) autopsy; (3) study of the placenta; (4) anatomo-histopathological observations concerning particular organs and structures potentially involved in postpartum maternal death; and (5) evaluation of physicians' behaviour, in the light of necroscopic findings and a review of the literature. The causes of death most frequently described in the postpartum period were excluded; a mediastinal nodular sclerosing Hodgkin's lymphoma with transdiaphragmatic diffusion, not diagnosed in life, was demonstrated. The cause of death was identified as intracerebral haemorrhage following DIC, Hodgkin's disease and recent delivery by caesarean section. Analysis of the physicians' conduct, together with a review of the literature, revealed a medical error. However, no causal relationship between the error and the death of the patient was considered to exist. The interest of the case lies in the unusual cause of DIC discussed in relation to a hypothesis of obstetric-gynaecological liability.

Ethical and medico-legal implications of capacity of patients in geriatric surgery

“…Consent which is not genuinely “informed,” as in the 18 cases described in our sample, may have importance from ethical and judicial standpoints. In Italy, a lawsuit for malpractice may be brought against a physician not only in the event of patients suffering damage causally linked to an error made by their doctor 26,27 but also if actions were carried out without valid informed consent on the part of patients (or their legal guardians).…”

The clinical management of diabetic foot in the elderly and medico-legal implications

“…Professional liability in Italy is based on the demonstrated occurrence of an error committed by a medical worker, causally related to damage to a patient 23,24 (passing from a healthy condition to a disease, to death, or suffering the aggravation of an already diagnosed disease). Professional liability may be disciplinary, civil, or criminal (e.g., manslaughter).…”

Death after an accidental fall of a 101 year old hospitalized patient. Medico-legal implication of falling in geriatrics

“…The methodological approach of evaluation of professional liability cases is based on the definition of damage to the patient (diagnosis of a disease or identification of the cause of death), on the analysis of the conduct of clinicians and on verification of causal relation between patient damage and the possible error of clinicians [14,15]. …”