W e examined the recovery of power in the muscles of the lower limb after fracture of the tibial diaphysis, using a Biodex dynamometer. Recovery in all muscle groups was rapid for 15 to 20 weeks following fracture after which it slowed. Two weeks after fracture the knee flexors and extensors have about 40% of normal power, which rises to 75% to 85% after one year. The dorsiflexors and plantar flexors of the ankle and the invertors and evertors of the subtalar joint are much weaker two weeks after injury, but at one year their mean power is more than that of the knee flexors and extensors.Our When treating a severely-injured limb the final outcome is usually determined by the extent of the injury to the soft tissues. There have been few reports on the recovery of muscle strength after fractures of the lower limb. Of these, most have been concerned with muscle recovery after fractures of the femur rather than of the tibia, 1-4 but the latter are much more common and tend to affect younger patients, many of whom are keen to return to sports and other activities. 5 We have examined the recovery of muscle groups of the lower limb after fracture of the tibial diaphysis with particular reference to the age of the patient, the mechanism of injury and the type of fracture.
Patients and MethodsBetween June 1994 and November 1996, 130 patients with isolated fractures of the tibia and fibula treated by intramedullary fixation were entered into the study. We excluded multiply-injured patients and those with more than one fracture in the limb, since their functional recovery would be affected by the extent and severity of other injuries, and patients who were unable to co-operate with the study protocol or who lived outside the local area. Of the 130, 30 failed to attend for follow-up, leaving 100 in the study. There were 81 men and 19 women with a mean age of 30.6 years (13 to 64). There were 87 closed and 13 open fractures. According to the AO classification 6 67 fractures were type A, 22 were type B and 11 were type C. Of the 87 closed fractures, eight were Tscherne 7 C0, 63 were C1, 14were C2 and the remaining two were C3. All fractures were classified by one consultant (CCB) to avoid interobserver variation. Open fractures were treated by debridement and primary nailing followed by re-exploration of the wound 36 to 48 hours after injury, with soft-tissue cover being carried out at the second procedure or shortly after. Closed fractures were treated by primary nailing. 8,9 A reamed GrosseKempf nail was used in all cases. Physiotherapy was started on the day after operation and weight-bearing was allowed as soon as it could be tolerated. Muscle function was assessed using a Biodex dynamometer (Biodex Medical Systems Inc, New York) at 2, 6, 10, 14, 18, 26, 39 and 52 weeks after injury to determe isokinetic peak torque, total work and the average power for knee flexion and extension, ankle dorsiflexion and plantar flexion and subtalar inversion and eversion. Each test consisted of an active period of warm-up followed by six ...