Positive Ulnar Fovea Sign – Audit of Patient Outcomes Following Nonsurgical and Surgical Management

Abstract

Background: Patients with ulnar-sided wrist pain and positive ulnar fovea sign are usually treated nonsurgically before surgical options are considered. However, the outcomes of nonsurgical management are unknown. Many of these patients also have unstable distal radioulnar joint, but there has been no comparison between the outcomes of these patients with stable and unstable distal radioulnar joint. The objectives of this study are to (1) determine the outcomes of nonsurgical and surgical treatment of patients with positive ulnar fovea sign, and (2) compare the outcomes of patients with stable and unstable distal radioulnar joint. Methods: A retrospective analysis of the outcomes of patients with ulnar sided wrist pain and positive fovea sign was performed from March 2009 to December 2014. Outcomes were measured based on patient-reported pain improvement, grip strength and range of motion of the affected wrist before and after treatment. A total of 100 wrists in 98 patients were reviewed. Results: 54% of wrists managed nonsurgically experienced pain improvement. 83% of wrists managed surgically experienced pain improvement. The mean grip strength increased by 2.8 kg and 2.7 kg, while the range of motion decreased by 14° and 5° after nonsurgical and surgical treatment respectively. When comparing patients with stable and unstable distal radioulnar joint, there were statistically more wrists with unstable distal radioulnar joint that experienced pain improvement after treatment. Conclusions: The study showed that there is a role for nonsurgical treatment for wrists with positive ulnar fovea sign with more than half of the patients experiencing pain improvement. We also found that positive ulnar fovea sign patients with unstable distal radioulnar joint had better pain outcomes compared to those with stable distal radioulnar joint.