Neurotransmission depends on the exocytic fusion of synaptic vesicles (SVs) and their subsequent reformation either by clathrinmediated endocytosis or budding from bulk endosomes. How synapses are able to rapidly recycle SVs to maintain SV pool size, yet preserve their compositional identity, is poorly understood. We demonstrate that deletion of the endocytic adaptor stonin 2 (Stn2) in mice compromises the fidelity of SV protein sorting, whereas the apparent speed of SV retrieval is increased. Loss of Stn2 leads to selective missorting of synaptotagmin 1 to the neuronal surface, an elevated SV pool size, and accelerated SV protein endocytosis. The latter phenotype is mimicked by overexpression of endocytosisdefective variants of synaptotagmin 1. Increased speed of SV protein retrieval in the absence of Stn2 correlates with an upregulation of SV reformation from bulk endosomes. Our results are consistent with a model whereby Stn2 is required to preserve SV protein composition but is dispensable for maintaining the speed of SV recycling.pHluorin | hippocampus | mossy fibers N eurotransmission involves the calcium-regulated fusion of synaptic vesicles (SVs), a process that requires the SV calcium sensor synaptotagmin (Syt) (1) and components of the active zone (AZ) that define sites of neurotransmitter release (2). Postexocytic fusion SV membranes are retrieved by endocytosis from the plasma membrane (2-5) to regenerate SVs of the correct size and composition (6). Alternatively, SVs can also be reformed from large plasma membrane infoldings and from endosomes (7) via a brefeldin A-sensitive pathway (8) that may become particularly important under conditions of sustained high-level activity and involves endosomal adaptor complexes such as adaptor protein complex 1 (AP-1) (9, 10). Maintenance of the SV pool requires that the number of recycled SVs closely matches those having undergone exocytosis. As SVs are characterized by a precise protein composition (11) that at least for some SV proteins including Syt1, VGLUT1, and SV2A displays little intervesicle variation (12), molecular mechanisms must exist to control the fidelity of SV protein sorting while maintaining the speed of exo-endocytosis.The mechanisms by which exo-endocytic balance and the fidelity of SV protein sorting are maintained are unknown. One possibility is that retrieval of SV proteins involves clustering (13,14), which would alleviate a need for specific sorting, even if multiple pathways of SV reformation are used (9, 10). However, data based on imaging of SV proteins tagged with the GFPderived pH sensor pHluorin indicate that exocytosed and newly endocytosed SV proteins are not identical, suggesting that intermixing between exocytosed and preexisting surface pools of vesicle proteins occurs (15,16). If SVs lose their identity over multiple rounds of exo-endocytosis, specific mechanisms should exist for the cargo-specific recognition and sorting of SV proteins, e.g., by adaptors (4, 15).Several components of the endocytic machinery may function as a...