Political polarization in social media: Analysis of the “Twitter political field” in Japan

Abstract

There is an ongoing debate about whether the Internet is like a public sphere or an echo chamber. Among many forms of social media, Twitter is one of the most crucial online places for political debate. Most of the previous studies focus on the formal structure of the Twitter political field, such as its homophilic tendency, or otherwise limits the analysis to a few topics. In order to explore whether Twitter functions as an echo chamber in general, however, we have to investigate not only the structure but also the contents of Twitter's political field. Accordingly, we conducted both large-scale social network analysis and natural language processing. We firstly applied a community detection method to the reciprocal following network in Twitter and found five politically distinct communities in the field. We further examined dominant topics discussed therein by employing a topic model in analyzing the content of the tweets, and we found that a topic related to xenophobia is circulated solely in right-wing communities. To our knowledge, this is the first study to address echo chambers in Japanese Twitter political field and to examine the formal structure and the contents of tweets with the combination of large-scale social network analysis and natural language processing.

A User Modeling Pipeline for Studying Polarized Political Events in Social Media

“…Furthermore, the age information of 40% and 45% of the users could be extracted for the Catalonia and Lombardy cases, respectively. For the Catalonia case, 4.9% were below 18, 22.1% were in range [18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30] [18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30], 37.6% were in range [31-45], 30.0% were in range of [46-65], and 2.6% were above 65. We can thus conclude that for both gender and age the two use cases display similar patterns about social media participation.…”

“…[10] claimed networks exhibit some level of homophily; as such, users tend to have contacts who have common shares with themselves. [20] claimed that there exists topic polarization among communities where each community acts as a sort of echo-chamber within itself.…”

The Impact of using Social Network on Academic Performance by using Contextual and Localized Data Analysis of Facebook Groups

“…[14] gives a good overview of sentiment analysis from social network's data of patients and application of NLP to mental health. Hiroki Takikawa [15] conducted both large-scale social network analysis and natural language processing on Japan's political Twitter data, they applied community detection method to identify the five most common communities they also use topic modelling technique their results also showed if topic is solely propagated by left or right wing. Glen Coppersmith et al [16] used natural language processing and machine learning techniques to detect quantifiable signals around suicide attempts.…”

How Do Japanese People Talk About Politics on Twitter? Analysis of Emotional Expressions in Political Topics on Japanese Twitter

“…In reference to this, social media, such as Twitter, is sometimes mentioned as an 'echo chamber' in which similar opinions, especially on political topics, can be repeated and polarised (e.g., Jackson, 2017). However, some studies that focused on Japanese or American Twitter users suggest that the echo chamber effect might change depending on the users' political position (Takikawa & Nagayoshi, 2017;Colleoni, Rozza, & Arvidsson, 2014). These studies imply that despite the limitation of propaganda through Twitter, a large number of tweets by other people might become an important factor in public opinion about politics in Japan.…”