Police and pastoral power: governmentality and correctional forensic psychiatric nursing*

Abstract

Police and pastoral power: governmentality and correctional forensic psychiatric nursing Since 1978, the federal inmates of Canada have had access to a full range of psychiatric care within the penitentiary system. Several psychiatric units are now integrated into the correctional services of Canada. This paper presents the results of a grounded theory doctoral study undertaken in a multilevel secured psychiatric ward within the Canadian federal penitentiary system. The author describes and discusses the results of qualitative data that emerged from his fieldwork. The concept of governmentality, as defined by the late French philosopher Michel Foucault, constitutes one of the major theoretical tools that were helpful in analyzing these data. Police and pastoral power, two dimensions of the security apparatus of governmentality, were found to be useful in understanding and characterizing nursing practice caught between the penal and the psychiatric dispositifs. A Foucauldian perspective allows one to understand the manner in which forensic psychiatric nursing is involved in the governance of mentally ill inmates through three forms of power - sovereign, disciplinary and pastoral - which have posited nursing practice as a strategic tool of the correctional services. This research consists of a study of nursing practice in an extreme setting that deserves a radical analysis.

The Mentally Ill and Social Exclusion: A Critical Examination of the Use of Seclusion From the Patient's Perspective

“…Showing someone respect while placing them in the seclusion room proves to be a difficult task (Lamothe, 1988). The problem that unfolds given the questions raised previously, is the contradiction between practicing nursing and exercising social control (Ashmore & Ramsamy, 1993;Gilbert, 1995;Holmes, 2001Holmes, , 2002Holmes & Gastaldo, 2002;Hopton, 1997aHopton, , 1997bHorsfall, 1997;Mason & Mercer, 1995;Naish, 1992;Rolfe, 1990;Sutor, 1993).…”

Expertise and humanity: the supportive professional relationship from the perspective of clients in drug treatment

“…A general challenge in professional interventions is that support is complicated by the fact that it contains an element of control (Foucault, 1979;Holmes, 2002). Control -as reflected in the balance of power between professionals and clients, and in rules and regulations that clients are expected to adapt to -can create structures that are perceived supportive, but can also be A reasonable conclusion could be that no matter how caring the professionals are and how much control exists for "the client's best", a key dimension in constructive support seems to be that the interaction not only is based on the formal power, but also rests strongly on "confirmed power" (Bernler & Johnson, 2001).…”

“…However, it is also a prerequisite for treatment by providing a medium for interventions, which are mediated in the relationship (Rogers, 1961;Vaux, 1988;Bernler & Johnson, 2001). The professional relationship is also complicated by the fact that it is unequal (Foucault, 1979;Billquist, 1999;Holmes, 2002). First, asymmetry is about the balance of power in the relationship where the client is in a dependent position, and where the professional has a superior position.…”

Making breathing your business: enterprising practices at the margins of orthodoxy

“…(1997: 182) Among the many theorists who have provided insights into the social construction of the professions, Michel Foucault's work (most especially, 1979;, and more latterly the writing of Nikolas Rose (1997;1999), form health: 13(3) the lens through which we have apprehended physiotherapy here. Over the last two decades, Foucault's work, and the writings of his peers Bourdieu, Cixous, Derrida, Deleuze and Guattari, Kristeva and Lyotard, have provided provocative insights that have enabled other social theorists to explore the social construction of medicine (Armstrong, 1995;Turner, 1997;Lupton and McLean, 1998;Petersen, 2003), dentistry (Nettleton, 1992;, nursing (Bjornsdottir, 2002;Clinton and Hazelton, 2002;Holmes and Gastaldo, 2002;Perron et al, 2005), psychology, counselling and mental health (Rose, 1997;Holmes, 2002;Ayllon, 2003;Brownlie, 2004).…”