Police and Culture: A Comparison between China and the United States

Abstract

Cross-cultural police studies allow an understanding of the range of variation and common elements in the field of policing. This article was written on the basis of information gathered on policing and its cultural environment in China and the United States. The relationship between police and culture was examined by comparing the Chinese and American police, taking into account the broader social processes and larger societal patterns. This article specifically illustrates how cultures as larger social contexts and as internalized values influence the organization, operations, and behaviors of police in these two countries. Some theoretical and policy implications for policing are discussed.

Occupational Culture in Policing Reviewed: A Comparison of Values in the Public and Private Police

“…We can only give a few examples of non Anglo-Saxon literature on police culture, e.g. in the Netherlands (Punch, 1979), France (Monjardet, 1994), Japan (Ames, 1981;Bayley, 1991), China (Jiao, 2001), and South Africa (Brogden and Shearing, 1993). Despite some indications of similar characteristics of police culture in non English-speaking parts of the world (e.g.…”

The evolution of criminal interrogation rules in China

“…Given that transients have no attachment, commitment, or involvement in communities, subjecting them to stronger formal control by the criminal justice system is deemed necessary by urban citizens to curtail crimes (Lu and Drass, 2002). Moreover, as police officers, following the ‚mass-line‛ in policing, actually live and work in a neighbourhood for a long time, most Chinese citizens do not view the police as a force limiting their freedom, but as a service resource they can rely on (Jiao, 2001). As a result, the formal law enforcement is shouldering more responsibility for solving crimes, thus reinforcing itself in both real and symbolic senses (Wong, 2001).…”

Relativism and Universalism in Interrogation Fairness: A Comparative Analysis Between Europe and China

“…Given that transients have no attachment, commitment, or involvement in communities, using the criminal justice system to subject them to stronger formal control is deemed necessary by urban citizens to curtail crime (Lu and Drass, 2002). Moreover, as police officers, following the 'mass-line' in policing, actually live and work in certain neighbourhoods for a long time, most Chinese citizens do not view the police as a force limiting their freedom, but as a service resource they can rely on (Jiao, 2001). As a result, the formal law enforcement is shouldering more responsibility for solving crimes, thus reinforcing itself in both real and symbolic senses (Wong, 2001).…”