Point-of-care ultrasound training for residents in anaesthesia and critical care: results of a national survey comparing residents and training program directors’ perspectives

Abstract

Background Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) has become an essential tool for anaesthesia and critical care physicians and dedicated training is mandatory. This survey describes the current state of Italian residency training programs through the comparison of residents’ and directors’ perspective. Methods Observational prospective cross-sectional study: 12-question national e-survey sent to Italian directors of anaesthesia and critical care residency programs (N = 40) and residents (N = 3000). Questions focused on POCUS teaching (vascular access, transthoracic echocardiography, focused assessment for trauma, transcranial Doppler, regional anaesthesia, lung and diaphragm ultrasound), organization (dedicated hours, teaching tools, mentors), perceived adequacy/importance of the training and limiting factors. Results Five hundred seventy-one residents and 22 directors completed the survey. Bedside teaching (59.4–93.2%) and classroom lessons (29.7–54.4%) were the most frequent teaching tools. Directors reported higher participation in research projects (p < 0.05 for all techniques but focused assessment for trauma) and simulation (p < 0.05 for all techniques but transthoracic echocardiography). Use of online teaching was limited (< 10%); however, 87.4% of residents used additional web-based tools. Consultants were the most frequent mentors, with different perspectives between residents (72.0%) and directors (95.5%; p = 0.013). Residents reported self-training more frequently (48.5 vs. 9.1%; p < 0.001). Evaluation was mainly performed at the bedside; a certification was not available in most cases (< 10%). Most residents perceived POCUS techniques as extremely important. Residents underestimated the relevance given by directors to ultrasound skills in their evaluation and the minimal number of exams required to achieve basic competency. Overall, the training was considered adequate for vascular access only (62.2%). Directors mainly agreed on the need of ultrasound teaching improvement in all fields. Main limitations were the absence of a standardized curriculum for residents and limited mentors’ time/expertise for directors. Conclusion POCUS education is present in Italian anaesthesia and critical care residency programs, although with potential for improvement. Significant discrepancies between residents’ and directors’ perspectives were identified.

Lung Ultrasound in Critical Care and Emergency Medicine: Clinical Review

“…Research will have to confirm this hypothesis. How to reach an adequate training, so far missing [ 81 , 107 ], is also a matter of concern.…”

Critical care echocardiography: barriers, competencies and solutions. A survey of over 600 participants

“…Although ultrasonography is a recognised component of the assessment of critically ill patients [4,[13][14][15][16], its adoption is still limited by several barriers. The biggest barrier identified by our survey preventing the widespread use of CCE is the lack of appropriate training [17][18][19][20][21], resulting in insufficient experience/skill of the clinical team to confidently perform and interpret the examination, despite most respondents feeling confident in acquiring basic CCE windows. Both experts and regular respondents agree that lack of experience/skill is a major issue limiting the implementation of bedside echocardiography Crucially, a 2017 survey by Galarza et al [21] showed that only five European countries had a national-accreditation programme, with supporting training structure, in this skill.…”

Lung ultrasound and supine chest X-ray use in modern adult intensive care: mapping 30 years of advancement (1993–2023)

“…The same is true for consolidation, an essential skill to differentiate between pneumonia, atelectasis, contusion and pulmonary embolism. It requires advanced skills supporting the idea that competence cannot easily be divided into basic and advanced skills [ 71 , 72 ].…”