Plant sexual reproduction: perhaps the current plant two-sex model should be replaced with three- and four-sex models?

Abstract

The two-sex model makes the assumption that there are only two sexual reproductive states: male and female. However, in land plants (embryophytes) the application of this model to the alternation of generations life cycle requires the subtle redefinition of several common terms related to sexual reproduction, which seems to obscure aspects of one or the other plant generation: For instance, the homosporous sporophytic plant is treated as being asexual, and the gametophytes of angiosperms treated like mere gametes. In contrast, the proposal is made that the sporophytes of homosporous plants are indeed sexual reproductive organisms, as are the gametophytes of heterosporous plants. This view requires the expansion of the number of sexual reproductive states we accept for these plant species; therefore, a three-sex model for homosporous plants and a four-sex model for heterosporous plants are described and then contrasted with the current two-sex model. These new models allow the use of sexual reproductive terms in a manner largely similar to that seen in animals, and may better accommodate the plant alternation of generations life cycle than does the current plant two-sex model. These new models may also help stimulate new lines of research, and examples of how they might alter our view of events in the flower, and may lead to new questions about sexual determination and differentiation, are presented. Thus it is suggested that land plant species have more than merely two sexual reproductive states and that recognition of this may promote our study and understanding of them.

Development and Evolution of Unisexual Flowers: A Review

“…The floral meristem initiates only androecial or gynoecial organs and does not go through a hermaphroditic stage [17]. This latter condition, known as dicliny (Box 2), is associated with a wide spectrum of gender (Box 2) systems that involve various combinations of female, male, and hermaphroditic flowers at the plant and population levels [3,18]. In his Regnum Vegetabile Secundum Systema Sexuale of his Systema Naturae, Linnaeus [14] (p. 23) distinguished hermaphroditic plants from plants having either male or female flowers.…”