Plain Language SummaryThe Early Eocene Climatic Optimum (EECO) is an interval of prolonged warmth that occurred ∼53 to 49 million years ago. Planktic foraminifera are important (alongside coccolithophores) for understanding the carbon cycle and determining export production in the ocean. To understand how foraminifera can be impacted by extreme heat, we analyzed samples from the Pacific Ocean through measuring changes in (a) the relative abundance, that is, the count of different taxa in a sample, and (b) body (shell) size of planktic foraminifera. At the start of the EECO, the abundance of the genera Morozovella and Chiloguembelina decreased. Despite this decline, the number of foraminifera being buried and the size of the largest shells in a sample does not change. We attribute this to the increased abundance of the genus Acarinina. In general, the accumulation of foraminifera remains stable while the relative abundance of foraminifera to coccolithophores decreases. Together, this implies that coccolithophores are increasing in abundance, and/or mass. During the EECO, one group of foraminifera was able to counterbalance the decrease in abundance of other genera. This highlights the resilience of open‐ocean carbonate production and the base of the marine food web.