“Place-Framing” as Place-Making: Constituting a Neighborhood for Organizing and Activism

Abstract

This article uses social-movement theory to analyze how neighborhood organizations portray activism as grounded in a particular place and scale. I apply the concept of collective-action frames to a case study of four organizations in a single neighborhood in St. Paul, Minnesota. Using organizational documents such as annual reports, comprehensive plans, and flyers, I present a discourse analysis of the ways that organizations describe their goals and agenda. In particular, I assess the extent to which the organizations characterize the neighborhood in their justifications of organizational goals and actions. In order to legitimate their own agendas and empower community activism, neighborhood organizations foster a neighborhood identity that obscures social differences, such as ethnicity and class, among residents. They do so by describing the physical condition of the neighborhood and the daily life experiences of its residents. These ''place-frames'' constitute a motivating discourse for organizations seeking to unite residents for a neighborhood-oriented agenda, despite very different substantive issues, from crime to land-use planning. This perspective allows for a more effective understanding of how place informs activism at a variety of spatial scales. Further, by inserting place into theories of collective-action framing, this research helps to introduce a new research agenda that addresses the gap between geographical analyses of territorial identities and activism and other scholarly literatures on contentious politics.

Occupied with Place: Exploring Twitter Resistance Networks

“…This includes the comparison of activism across global and local scales (Kurtz, 2003;Martin, 2007), neighborhood or community-based organizing (Elwood, 2008(Elwood, , 2006Martin, 2007), institutional hierarchies (Leitner et al, 2008;Martin et al, 2003) and place-framing, the legitimization of an agenda by constituting place identity through communicative framing (Martin, 2003). Occupy drew inspiration from international resistances that formed in the place of the public squares of Tehran and Spain.…”

The Problems of Tourist Sustainability in Cultural Cities: Socio-Political Perceptions and Interests Management

“…Neighbours come together and carry out different actions [62], including protests against the more negative repercussions of tourism. They say they do not see the money tourism makes, only the negative consequences: "They talk about the millions left by visitors and maybe they are right but that money, in whose hands is it now?…”

‘We want to be there for everyone’: imagined spaces of encounter and the politics of place in a super-diverse neighbourhood

“…From the side of neighbourhood organizations, there is an incentive to establish community and create an overarching vision for the neighbourhood (Leitner, 2012), since doing so is necessary to access political and economic resources. By focusing on situated and shared experiences, internal differences are obscured and the neighbourhood is constituted as the appropriate scale of action (Martin, 2003a). If local organizations are successful in bringing together residents of diverse backgrounds, they can potentially function as micro-publics (Amin, 2002), creating positive encounters and successful cooperation across group boundaries (Fincher & Iveson, 2008).…”