Picturing Mental Health on Instagram: Insights from a Quantitative Study Using Different Content Formats

Abstract

Background: COVID-19 has changed individual lives to the core. Through national curfews and social distancing, individuals’ social lives changed and led to increased levels of stress and mental health problems. As another consequence, communication, especially among young people, has shifted to social networking sites, where particularly young adults sought help for their mental health problems. In recent years, Instagram has received recognition for its health-enhancing potentials. On this social networking site, more than 1 billion users worldwide post 500 million stories and images per day. Methods: During COVID-19, increasing mental health incidences were reported throughout the world, and have led mental health influencers to gain in relevance. The proposed study is based on a quantitative survey. In order to test how different content formats utilized by mental health influencers —motivational quotes, comics, or influencer posts—are evaluated by Instagram users, a cross-sectional quantitative study was conducted in April 2021. Data collection was based on convenience sampling. In total, 532 Austrian respondents between 16 and 34 years of age participated in the survey. Results: Overall, the content that received the most favorable evaluations were both the motivational quote (M = 4.23) and the influencer post (M = 4.12), while the comics scored lower in terms of evaluations (M = 3.72). Conclusions: Respondents’ preference of content suggests that individuals seek out content that boosts their esteem or content with a “human touch”. Explanations as to why the selected content formats were preferred over the other formats are offered alongside a future research outlook.

Bipolar Disorder in Social Media: An Examination of Instagram's Role in Disseminating Accurate Information

“…Studies have also shown that postings on social media lessen the stigma attached to mental health problems [ 5 , 6 ]. While the accompanying content may include true elements and details that define the topic, it may also include modified, incorrect, or irrelevant information that alters how users perceive information and the behaviors and beliefs that go along with it [ 7 , 8 ]. Thus, it is important to understand the accuracy and dependability of the information available on these platforms.…”

The Importance of Behavioral and Native Factors on COVID-19 Infection and Severity: Insights from a Preliminary Cross-Sectional Study

“…In fact, social media networks, especially Facebook, are now commonly used in medical research, specifically for cross-sectional design, and many studies have demonstrated its usefulness for quickly recruiting a large sample at the lowest cost [ 92 , 93 , 94 ]. Concerning other social media, although they are a little more recent than Facebook, their use is becoming more and more democratized in new studies, especially Instagram [ 95 , 96 ] and WhatsApp [ 97 , 98 ]. At the same time, we required that the respondents should be at least 18 years old to participate and asked for confirmation from each respondent.…”

The Benefits of Instagram on Teenagers’ Mental Health

“…Studies have also uncovered that social media messages can help to reduce mental health issues and the stigmatization associated therewith. [6] On social media like Instagram, there are multiple types of peer support for mental health, especially for people who are having hard times during the COVID-19 pandemic. Four forms of support can be distinguished: informational support, esteem support, emotional support, and network support.…”

“…At this point, the role of the influencer comes into play again, according to the study, …influencers thus started to thematize their personal mental health struggles, utilizing the diverse and varied presentation modes available on Instagram, which can increase both the visibility and relevance of the mental health discussion on social media. [6] Influencers informally affect the attitudes and opinions of their followers by posting mental health-related things that make their followers become aware of such issues. In the case of spreading messages, influencers and celebrities have similar functions because both of them are deemed credible and reliable by the public crowd, therefore anything they say or do greatly affects what the public crowd says or does.…”