Physico-chemical thresholds in the distribution of fish species among French lakes

Abstract

-The management of lakes requires the definition of physico-chemical thresholds to be used for ecosystem preservation or restoration. According to the European Water Framework Directive, the limits between physico-chemical quality classes must be set consistently with biological quality elements. One way to do this consists in analyzing the response of aquatic communities to environmental gradients across monitoring sites and in identifying ecological community thresholds, i.e. zones in the gradients where the species turnover is the highest. In this study, fish data from 196 lakes in France were considered to derive ecological thresholds using the multivariate method of gradient forest. The analysis was performed on 25 species and 36 environmental parameters. The results revealed the highest importance of maximal water temperature in the distribution of fish species. Other important parameters included geographical factors, dissolved organic carbon concentration and water transparency, while nutrients appeared to have low influence. In spite of the diversity of species responses to the gradients, community thresholds were detected in the gradients of the most important physico-chemical parameters and of total phosphorus and nitrate concentrations as well. The thresholds identified in such macroecological study may highlight new patterns of species natural distribution and improve niche characterization. Moreover, when factors that may be influenced by human activities are involved, the thresholds could be used to set environmental standards for lake preservation.Keywords: ecological threshold / gradient forest / fish / lake / water quality Résumé -Seuils physico-chimiques dans la distribution des poissons des plans d'eau français.La gestion des plans d'eau nécessite la définition de seuils physico-chimiques pour la préservation ou la restauration des écosystèmes. Selon la Directive Cadre européenne sur l'Eau, les limites de classes de qualité physico-chimiques doivent être fixées en cohérence avec les éléments de qualité biologique. Une façon de faire consiste à analyser les réponses des communautés aquatiques aux gradients environnementaux formés par les sites de monitoring et d'identifier des seuils écologiques de communautés, c'est-à-dire des zones dans les gradients où le turnover des espèces est le plus important. Dans cette étude, les données de pêches provenant de 196 plans d'eau ont été considérées pour rechercher des seuils écologiques avec la méthode de gradient forest. L'analyse a porté sur 25 espèces avec 36 paramètres environnementaux. Les résultats ont révélé que la température maximale était le facteur le plus important dans la distribution des espèces de poissons. Les autres paramètres importants étaient les facteurs géographiques, la concentration en carbone organique dissous et la transparence de l'eau alors que les nutriments semblaient avoir peu d'influence. Malgré la diversité de réponses des espèces aux gradients, des seuils de communautés ont été détectés dans les gradients des p...

Threshold responses of riverine fish communities to land use conversion across regions of the world

“…The threshold values indicate where the first substantial change in fish community composition occurs in relation to increasing urban and agricultural land use. We generated 1,000 trees for each RF model and used default constrained permutations with correlation threshold of 0.5 to reduce the influence of multicollinearity (Ellis et al., 2012; Roubeix et al., 2017). Relative abundance data was arcsine square root transformed to meet statistical requirements, whereas GF are invariant to monotonic transformations of the explanatory variables (Wagenhoff et al., 2017).…”

“…The threshold values indicate where the first substantial change in fish community composition occurs in relation to increasing urban and agricultural land use. We generated 1,000 trees for each RF model and used default constrained permutations with correlation threshold of 0.5 to reduce the influence of multicollinearity (Ellis et al, 2012;Roubeix et al, 2017).…”

An epilimnion and hypolimnion temperature model based on air temperature and lake characteristics

“…In particular, environmental agencies and stakeholders are most interested in high temperatures, which can cause mortality and thermal stress (Caissie et al, 2001;Davies-Colley et al, 2013). In fact, in France maximum annual water temperature is the main parameter determining the composition of the fish community in lakes (Roubeix et al, 2017). However, low temperatures are important too.…”

Structure of small tropical island freshwater fish and crustacean communities: A niche‐or dispersal‐based process?

“…A total of 153 surveys in Mayotte, and 262 in Reunion, were included in these analyses due to missing data. The average R 2 was 0.19 in Mayotte and 0.28 in Reunion, which means that the variance in species abundances was moderately explained by environmental variables in both islands (Roubeix et al., 2017). The four taxa for which the total deviance was best explained by GF were Ophieleotris cf.…”

“…This latter advantage appeared particularly relevant in the context of our study as data preview revealed nonlinear relationships between taxa abundances and several environmental variables. To limit the bias caused by rare species, GF analyses were performed on species occurring in more than 3.5% of the surveys only (Roubeix et al., 2017).…”