We report a switchable time-varying mirror, composed of an ITO-Au stack, which can be efficiently modulated in time with over a ten-fold increase in reflectivity, with a change of 0.6. Upon interacting with the time-varying mirror, the frequency content of a reflected pulse is extended to 31 THz. This originates from the shortening of the response time of the mirror beyond saturation, as confirmed by a time-varying model and by further four-wave mixing experiments. A temporal response unbounded by the pump bandwidth opens new avenues for spectral manipulation from time-varying systems with impact for communication networks, optical switching and computing.