A common technique for introducing rare earth atoms into Si and related materials for photonic applications is ion implantation. It is compatible with standard Si processing, and also allows high, non-equilibrium concentrations of rare earths to be introduced. However, the high energies often employed mean that there are collision cascades and potentially severe end-of-range damage. This paper reports on studies of this damage, and the competition it may present to the optical activity of the rare earths. Er-, Si, and Yb-implanted Si samples have been investigated, before and after anneals designed to restore the sample crystallinity. The electrical activity of defects in as-implanted Er, Si, and Yb doped Si has been studied by Deep Level Transient Spectroscopy (DTLS) and the related, high resolution technique, Laplace DLTS (LDLTS), as a function of annealing. Er-implanted Si, regrown by solid phase epitaxy at 600degrees C and then subject to a rapid thermal anneal, has also been studied by time-resolved photoluminescence (PL). The LDLTS studies reveal that there are clear differences in the defect population as a function of depth from the surface, and this is attributed to different defects in the vacancy-rich and interstitial-rich regions. Defects in the interstitial-rich region have electrical characteristics typical of small extended defects, and these may provide the precursors for larger structural defects in annealed layers. The time-resolved PL of the annealed layers, in combination with electron microscopy, shows that the Er emission at 1.54microns contains a fast component attributed to non-radiative recombination at deep states due to small dislocations.It is 2 concluded that there can be measurable competition to the radiative efficiency in rare-earth implanted Si that is due to the implantation and is not specific to Er. One of the underlying problems of using rare earth emission in Si as a host is the relative lifetimes of various parallel processes. The radiative lifetime of the Er can be many milliseconds in an insulator and is reduced by faster non-radiative recombination in Si, an effect which is increasingly prevalent as the temperature rises. A further complication arises in ion implantation, as the implantation introduces defects which can be hard to remove. The microelectronics industry currently has issues with ion implantation damage being responsible for various processing bottlenecks, for example, the phenomenon of Transient Enhanced Diffusion (TED).[5] In TED, the implanted boron atoms diffuse away from their intended location, because their interstitial-assisted diffusion is enhanced by the interstitials created during implantation. If implant-related damage remains after an anneal, it is typically seen as end-ofrange loops. Such loops are known to have associated electrical activity [6] and optical activity, [7] and therefore are of critical importance in device design and subsequent functionality. They are formed from an excess of interstitials which have been unable either to reco...