Photographs and accountability: cracking the codes of an NGO

Abstract

Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to formulate an analytical model for interpreting photographs in accountability statements from Barthes' celebrated theoretical work on photography, La chambre claire; to offer a study of the communication of accountability by an NGO through the first detailed analysis, within accountability literature, of one photograph. Design/methodology/approach -The study establishes a conceptual framework for examining photography based on La chambre claire's contrast of rational codes (Studium) with intuitive elements (Punctum). An application of the framework is provided in considering the heterogeneity and accountability of NGOs through an examination of the Oxfam Annual Review 2003/2004 front cover photograph. Findings -The framework is enlightening: the photograph's Studium reflects the complexity of Oxfam's dual engagement in the corporate and charitable sectors, and the developed and developing worlds; its Punctum arouses sentiment and compassion.Research limitations/implications -The study provides a model which may be applied to the wealth of photographs produced by contemporary organizations; the framework encompasses promotional images as well as photographic art, and is well suited to figurative photography. It is limited regarding photographs of a hybrid or abstract nature. Practical implications -The analysis is of interest to accounting researchers, practitioners, trainees, auditors and any user of accounting and accountability statements. It illuminates the way in which photographs highlight, complement and supplement information more traditionally communicated in numbers and words. Originality/value -The paper adds to research into NGOs; augments theoretical work on photographs in accountability literature; and expands the empirical literature on the interpretation of photographs in accounting and accountability statements.

The first 25 years of the Queensland Rugby Football League: Claims to legitimacy in annual reports

“…The unique nature of QRFL limits the application of some of these findings to other NFP entities, however the legitimacy framework developed would be useful for investigating the annual reports of other sporting organizations, and for assessing the implications of changes over time. Further research on the use of images in the annual reports of sporting organizations would also be of interest in order to highlight their contribution to a language of success (Davison, 2007).…”

“…Despite accountants' opinions that such visual images in annual reports are "lightweight elements of annual report packaging" (Davison, 2007: 137), it has been acknowledged that they contain rich and potent messages that can be useful in shaping corporate identity and reputation (Davison, 2007;Davison and Warren, 2009;Cho et al, 2009).…”

The Visual Dimension in Organizing, Organization, and Organization Research: Core Ideas, Current Developments, and Promising Avenues

“…They regard visuals as produced, as well as interpreted, in a specific cultural and historical context, thus making use of shared cues and symbols in order to be comprehensible. In this way, visual artifacts construct organizational reality (e.g., Kuasirikun, 2011), transport corporations' claims regarding truth, credibility, and authenticity (e.g., Graves, Flesher, & Jordan, 1996;Guthey & Jackson, 2005), and/or signal accountability (e.g., Breitbarth, Harris, & Insch, 2010;Davison, 2007;Höllerer, Jancsary, Meyer, & Vettori, forthcoming). Still, part of the messages conveyed through visuals is potentially unintended, and, consequently, opens up opportunities for the systematic reconstruction of implicit and taken-for-granted understandings and values (e.g., Dougherty & Kunda, 1990;.…”

Sustainability Reporting, Visuals and Photographs: A Case Study

“…The author has followed the work of Davison (2007) who firstly has embraced the work of Roland Barthes "La chambre claire" (1980) for her assessment of the role and impact of photographs in the accounting and sustainability reports.…”