“…In the combination of elements detected after Ar etching, the possible chemical states of Tl are Tl 0 , Tl 2 O, Tl 2 O 3 , and TlBr, corresponding to energies of 117.1, 119.1, 118.6, and 119.2 eV, respectively. (13) Since the energy of Tl 0 is close to the measured energy of the subpeak, it was concluded that the subpeak represents Tl 0 . The main Tl 4f peak was considered to be mainly TlBr; thus, we expressed it as Tl (TlBr).…”