Survival analysis based on consumers' acceptance or rejection of milk of different storage ages, was used to validate the shelf life of low fat UHT milk in high density polyethylene (HDPE) bottles, as determined by a multivariate accelerated shelf life test (MASLT) in a prior study (Richards, De Kock, & Buys, 2014). UHT milk samples between 120 and 290 d of storage were evaluated. On the basis of 50% of consumers rejecting the product, the shelf life of the UHT milk was estimated to be 214 d, validating the shelf life of 211 d estimated by the MASLT. In addition to this, consumers were asked to complete check-all-that-apply (CATA) attribute questions and rate the acceptability of the milk. Physico-chemical and enzymatic properties of the UHT milk of various ages was also evaluated. The consumers noted positive sensory attributes more frequently in fresher milk samples with an increase in negative attributes with storage. Along with this, the hedonic scores for the UHT milk also decreased and physico-chemical and enzymatic reactions associated with the deterioration of UHT milk increased as the milk was stored for longer time periods.