The use of echocardiography, phonocardiography, and spectroanalysis has enhanced the ability to detect prosthetic valve dysfunction even before the onset of symptoms in many patients. Reduction in the intensity of the opening and closing clicks and the appearance of new murmurs have been the most frequently reported observations in predicting prosthetic valve dysfunction. Simultaneous echocardiography, phonocardiography, and spectroanalysis were performed on 31 patients with Starr-Edwards prosthetic aortic valves. Eighteen patients had valves with metal (titanium or 'stellite') poppets, and 13 had valves with non-metal (silastic) poppets. In all patients with normally functioning valves with metal poppets, there were multiple systolic clicks on auscultation and confirmed by phonocardiography and spectroanalysis. In none of the patients with non-metal poppets were there clicks other than those associated with the normal opening and closing movements of the poppets. Three of the 18 patients with metal poppets did not manifest multiple systolic clicks, yet the cut-offfrequencies on spectroanalysis for opening and closing clicks in 1 of these patients were normal. Prosthetic valve dysfunction was shown in all 3 patients by cardiac catheterisation or at operation. We conclude that multiple systolic clicks are normal for patients with Starr-Edwards prosthetic aortic valves with metal (titanium or 'stellite') poppets, and that the absence of multiple systolic clicks may indicate prosthetic valve dysfunction even when the cut-off frequencies of the opening and closing clicks are normal.Because of the large number and different types of prosthetic valves, it is essential that the clinician be familiar with the normal characteristics of each type. Spectroanalysis is a fairly new technique used to complement the information obtained by echocardiographic and phonocardiographic examination (Winters et al., 1967;Hylen et al., 1969;Waxler et al., 1973;Gordon et al., 1974). This paper compares two types of Starr-Edwards prosthetic aortic valves-one with a metal (titanium or 'stellite') poppet and one with a non-metal (silastic) poppetand shows how spectroanalysis can distinguish between the two valve types and indicate valve dysfunction as well.
Subjects and methods