Phenotypic and Genetic Structure Support Gene Flow Generating Gene Tree Discordances in an Amazonian Floodplain Endemic Species

Abstract

Before populations become independent evolutionary lineages, the effects of micro evolutionary processes tend to generate complex scenarios of diversification that may affect phylogenetic reconstruction. Not accounting for gene flow in species tree estimates can directly impact topology, effective population sizes and branch lengths, and the resulting estimation errors are still poorly understood in wild populations. In this study, we used an integrative approach, including sequence capture of ultra-conserved elements (UCEs), mtDNA Sanger sequencing and morphological data to investigate species limits and phylogenetic relationships in face of gene flow in an Amazonian endemic species (Myrmoborus lugubris: Aves). We used commonly implemented species tree and model-based approaches to understand the potential effects of gene flow in phylogenetic reconstructions. The genetic structure observed was congruent with the four recognized subspecies of M. lugubris. Morphological and UCEs data supported the presence of a wide hybrid zone between M. l. femininus from the Madeira river and M. l. lugubris from the Middle and lower Amazon river, which were recovered as sister taxa by species tree methods. When fitting gene flow into simulated demographic models with different topologies, the best-fit model indicated these two taxa as non-sister lineages, a finding that is in agreement with the results of mitochondrial and morphological analyses. Our results demonstrated that failing to account for gene flow when estimating phylogenies at shallow divergence levels can generate topological uncertainty, which can nevertheless be statistically well supported, and that model testing approaches using simulated data can be useful tools to test alternative phylogenetic hypotheses.

Bird assemblages on Amazonian river islands: Patterns of species diversity and composition

“…This population structure among island specialists suggests that historical events, such as fluctuations in sea level, climate change, and tectonic activity (Bertani, Rossetti, Hayakawa & Cohen, ; Nogueira, Silveira & Guimarães, ), are relevant to the interpretation of current distribution of these species (Choueri et al., ). Endemism at the intraspecific lineage level, therefore, could be an important characteristic of birds specialized in river islands as indicated by preliminary studies (Choueri et al., ; Thom et al., ).…”

Reticulate evolution in nuclear Middle America causes discordance in the phylogeny of palm‐pitvipers (Viperidae: Bothriechis)

“…As genomic datasets have become increasingly available, there has been a corresponding rise in the identification and recognition of complex evolutionary histories (Arcila et al., ; Jeffroy et al., ; Thom et al., ). Our phylogenomic analysis of Bothriechis reveals reticulate evolution in nuclear Middle America leading to conflict in the phylogenetic placement of some lineages.…”

Similar but different: Revealing the relative roles of species‐traits versus biome properties structuring genetic variation in South American marsh rats

“…Given the recent origin of the marsh rat taxa (Machado, Leite, Christoff, & Giuliano, ), these biome‐specific properties, not more ancient Miocene and Pliocene climatic changes (Hoorn et al., ), are a logical starting point for testing the potential effects of biome‐specific properties on genetic variation in constituent taxa. Moreover, with few information on the physiogamy of regions and potential impact of Pleistocene climatic changes on wetland habitats specifically (see Aleixo, ; Ledru, Montade, Blanchard, & Hély, ; Leite et al., ; McGlue et al., ; Thom et al., ), differences in the genetic structure of constituent taxa across biomes, and any correspondence with regional properties can be mutually informative (e.g. Ferreira et al., ; Thom et al., ).…”