“…A series of validation studies has been conducted in different region, and showed some similar results, such as a relatively low number of category C patients, significant heterogeneity in prospective exacerbation rates in category D, no differences in the predictive value of mortality for GOLD 2011 and GOLD 2007, and a better predictive value of exacerbation for GOLD 2011 and GOLD 2007 [18]. KOBLIZEK et al [4] also compared Spanish phenotypes with GOLD categories (2011 version) and showed that the majority of frequent exacerbators were in category D regardless of the coexistence of chronic bronchitis, whereas 39% of non-exacerbators and 56% of those with ACOS were also in category D, indicating marked heterogeneity in this category. In the 2017 update of GOLD, lung function (GOLD stages 1-4) is considered independent of the assessment of GOLD categories A-D, the predictive values of which need to be validated [2].…”