Perspectives on communication in labor and delivery: A focus group analysis

Abstract

Objective: The objective of this study was to elicit and explore perceptions of barriers to optimal communication among clinicians on a labor and delivery unit, and to use this information to select and design approaches to improve communication.Study Design: A qualitative research design using a focus group format was utilized. Attending and resident obstetricians and anesthesiologists, as well as staff nurses, pharmacists and unit secretaries participated in the focus groups, which were recorded and transcribed. Data were analyzed using a framework analysis approach.Result: In total, 18 focus groups with a total of 92 participants were conducted. Eight key themes emerged regarding specific barriers to effective communication among clinicians in the labor and delivery setting. The most prominent of these themes included issues with inter-departmental coordination, clinical accessibility (the ability to reach other clinicians), lack of a consistent approach for clinical documentation, and the involvement of multiple care providers. On the basis of these themes, multiple interventions were designed to enhance communication. Conclusion:Focus group methodology can be used to elicit a detailed description of communication practices of clinicians on a labor and delivery unit, permitting an exploration of specific barriers to communication and the identification of potential solutions to those barriers.

Healthcare providers' perceptions of breastfeeding peer counselors in the neonatal intensive care unit

“…The framework approach was chosen to analyze the data, as it is designed to facilitate a detailed examination of the nature and range of people's experiences, the needs of the study population, and the elements that affect the successful implementation of a new program or service (Ritchie & Spencer, 1994). The framework approach was developed for qualitative research in the areas of social and public policy, but has been refined over the years and has developed into a versatile analytic approach across a range of healthcare studies in areas such as the meaning of autism for families, communication in labor and delivery, and healthcare‐seeking in South Africa (Calzada, Pistrang, & Mandy, 2012; Grobman et al, 2011; Sharkey, Chopra, Jackson, Winch, & Minkovitz, 2011).…”

Contributions of Clinical Disconnections and Unresolved Conflict to Failures in Intrapartum Safety

“…Miscommunication is a common and significant cause of safety issues (Grobman et al, 2011; Kennedy & Lyndon, 2008; Lyndon et al, 2012; Maxfield, Grenny, Lavandero, & Groah, 2011; Maxfield, Grenny, McMillan, Patterson, & Switzer, 2005; Simpson, James, & Knox, 2006). Several groups have demonstrated improvement in the culture of safety and presumably communication and teamwork in perinatal settings (Pettker et al, 2011; Simpson, Knox, Martin, George, & Watson, 2011; Thanh, Jacobs, Wanke, Hense, & Sauve, 2010).…”

An Exploratory Study of the Relationship between Facility Design and the Provision of Childbirth Care

“…In childbirth specifically, the unit design has been identified as a factor that affects communication and team decision making, corresponding with our theme of sharing knowledge and workload. Focus groups with nurses, obstetricians, residents, and other clinical and support staff working with labor and delivery suggested that communication can be affected by the locations of key patient care information (eg, in bedside documentation, on shared boards, or in the electronic records) and the technology available in the unit for communication among team members . Another observational study in 4 maternity units in England suggested that having a centralized location in the unit that captured and presented all key information about all women's statuses and care plans was a key factor in facilitating situational awareness for clinical teams .…”