Perspectives of Patients and Therapists on Social Media and Digital Data Use in Mental Health Therapy: Thematic Analysis

Southwick, Lauren; Suh, Rebecca; Kranzler, Elissa C.; Bradley, Megan; Merchant, Raina M.

doi:10.2196/32103

Cited by 4 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 25 publications

(32 reference statements)

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Clinicians reported enthusiasm for the prospect of potentially integrating data from young people’s mood-monitoring apps or social media to enable better assessments, and young people overall felt comfortable sharing data with clinicians. This fits with other preliminary research in this area [ 31 ]. However, young people remained skeptical of the idea of this happening during mental health consultations, with the majority reporting that they would not want this when presented with a binary choice.…”

Section: Discussionsupporting

confidence: 93%

Digital Technology Use and Mental Health Consultations: Survey of the Views and Experiences of Clinicians and Young People

Rifkin-Zybutz¹,

Turner²,

Derges³

et al. 2023

JMIR Ment Health

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Background Digital technologies play an increasingly important role in the lives of young people and have important effects on their mental health. Objective We aimed to explore 3 key areas of the intersection between digital technology and mental health: the views and experiences of young people and clinicians about digital technology and mental health; implementation and barriers to the UK national guidance recommendation—that the discussion of digital technology use should form a core part of mental health assessment; and how digital technology might be used to support existing consultations. Methods Two cross-sectional web-based surveys were conducted in 2020 between June and December, with mental health clinicians (n=99) and young people (n=320). Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the proportions. Multilinear regression was used to explore how the answers varied by gender, sexuality, and age. Thematic analysis was used to explore the contents of the extended free-text answers. Anxiety was measured using the Generalized Anxiety Disorder Questionnaire-7 (GAD-7). Results Digital technology use was ubiquitous among young people, with positive and negative aspects acknowledged by both clinicians and young people. Negative experiences were common (131/284, 46.1%) and were associated with increased anxiety levels among young people (GAD-7 3.29; 95% CI 1.97-4.61; P<.001). Although the discussion of digital technology use was regarded as important by clinicians and acceptable by young people, less than half of clinicians (42/85, 49.4%) routinely asked about the use of digital technology and over a third of young people (48/121, 39.6%) who had received mental health care had never been asked about their digital technology use. The conversations were often experienced as unhelpful. Helpful conversations were characterized by greater depth and exploration of how an individual’s digital technology use related to mental health. Despite most clinicians (59/83, 71.1%) wanting training, very few (21/86, 24.4%) reported receiving training. Clinicians were open to viewing mental health data from apps or social media to help with consultations. Although young people were generally, in theory, comfortable sharing such data with health professionals, when presented with a binary choice, most reported not wanting to share social media (84/117, 71.8%) or app data (67/118, 56.8%) during consultations. Conclusions Digital technology use was common, and negative experiences were frequent and associated with anxiety. Over a third of young people were not asked about their digital technology use during mental health consultations, and potentially valuable information about relevant negative experiences on the web was not being captured during consultations. Clinicians would benefit from having access to training to support these discussions with young people. Although young people recognized that app data could be helpful to clinicians, they appeared hesitant to share their own data. This finding suggests that data sharing has barriers that need to be further explored.

show abstract

Section: Discussionsupporting

confidence: 93%