Persisting in Physics and the Physics Olympiad — Impact of Gender Identification and Sense of Belonging on Expectancy-Value Outcomes

Abstract

The German Physics Olympiad is an extracurricular science contest for students. Here, they have the opportunity to compete against other talented students, can do physics outside of school, and take a first step to more engagement in the domain. Yet, female students participate in the competition in fewer numbers and are disproportionally more likely to drop out of the contest earlier than the male students.The present study hence explored the question to which extent the German Physics Olympiad provides a threatening environment for female contestants’ intentions of persisting in physics. A total of 298 participants (28% female) were surveyed with respect to stereotype and social identity threat, as well as gender identification and sense of belonging as predictors of success expectations for and value of choosing to study physics. Success expectations and value of choosing to study physics were used as a measure for career intentions within the expectancy-value model.The results support the conclusion that the contest presents an equally supporting environment for female and male participants. We found no gender differences in success expectations for and value of studying physics. Sense of belonging and gender identification significantly predicted success expectations but not value of choosing to study physics. Female participants in the German Physics Olympiad were also neither affected by stereotype threat nor by social identity threat in their sense of belonging or gender identification.

Belonging in engineering: Exploring the predictive relevance of social interaction and individual factors on undergraduate students' belonging in engineering

“…The value that students assign to their academic tasks and disciplines affects their attachment to learning activities and environments via motivation. Regarding the link between belonging and valuing, a study of high school students in Germany found that a more heightened sense of belonging positively affected students' expectations for success within the expectancy-value framework (Ladewig et al, 2022). A study of middle school students found significant correlations between belonging and value (Goodenow, 1993).…”

Differential relations among expectancy, task value, engagement, and academic performance: The role of generation status

“…Specifically, FGCS would report lower expectancyvalue motivation and engagement than CGCS if they experienced cultural mismatch. Finally, psychological factors, including sense of belonging (Gopalan and Brady, 2020;Ladewig et al, 2022) and stress (Simons and Steele, 2020), are predictors of motivation and engagement, suggesting that FGCS would be at most risk of experiencing lower expectancy-value motivation and engagement for school compared to CGCS.…”

Stereotypes in the German Physics Olympiad - Hurdle or no Harm at all?

“…The study presented in this paper was part of the larger project "Identiphy -Identity development in physics!" (see also Ladewig et al, 2022). The project included a longitudinal study with two cohorts of German Physics Olympiad participants.…”