Perianesthetic mortality in English Bulldogs: a retrospective analysis in 2010 – 2017

Abstract

Background Many veterinarians consider English Bulldogs to have a greater perianesthetic mortality risk. The aims of this study were to 1) determine total and anesthesia-related, perianesthetic mortality (PAM) rates in English Bulldogs (EB), 2) identify potential risk factors associated with mortality in EB, and 3) determine the difference in the perianesthetic mortality rates between EB, other-brachycephalic breeds (OB), and non-brachycephalic breeds (NB). Records from EB that were anesthetized between 2010 and 2017, were investigated. OB and NB were enrolled to match with each EB based on a procedure and age from the study period. Data collected in EB included: age, ASA status, weight, procedure types, anesthetic and analgesic management, anesthetic duration, anesthetic recovery location, and cause of death. Age and cause of death were determined from OB and NB. Fisher’s exact test was used to compare PAM rate and age in EB, OB, and NB. Mann–Whitney U test was used to compare EB survivor and EB non-survivor. Logistic regression models were used to identify factors and odds ratio (OR) associated with PAM in EB. Result Two hundred twenty nine EB, 218 OB, and 229 NB were identified. The total and anesthesia-related PAM rates in EB were 6.6 and 3.9%, respectively. EB had a greater total PAM rate compared with OB (p = 0.007). ASA status was different between survivors and non-survivors in EB (p < 0.01). Risk factors identified regardless of the cause of death were premedication with full μ opioids (OR = 0.333, p = 0.114), continuous infusion of ketamine post-operatively (OR = 13.775, p = 0.013), and acepromazine administration post-operatively (OR = 7.274, p = 0.004). The most common cause of death in EB was postoperative respiratory dysfunction (87.5%). Conclusion Total and anesthesia-related mortality in EB is considerable. Most deaths in EB occurred during the postoperative period secondary to respiratory complications.

A Review of Clinical Outcomes, Owner Understanding and Satisfaction following Medial Canthoplasty in Brachycephalic Dogs in a UK Referral Setting (2016–2021)

“…Several studies have documented higher anaesthetic risk in brachycephalic dogs compared to non-brachycephalic dogs [ 50 , 51 ]. In the present study, only one patient (1.6%, 1/64) was reported by the owner to have experienced a post-operative complication associated with their breathing, which is lower than what has been reported in other literature [ 50 , 52 ]. This may also reflect the specialist anaesthesia service in a referral setting.…”

Respiratory Effects of Continuous Positive Airway Pressure Administered during Recovery from General Anesthesia in Brachycephalic Dogs

“…Consequently, peri-anesthetic mortality rates in brachycephalic breeds are considerably higher than those in non-brachycephalic breeds. Most deaths in brachycephalic breeds occur during the postoperative period mainly due to respiratory complications [ 21 ]. Therefore, postoperative airway management in these breeds is paramount, aiming to mitigate the natural tendency for airway obstruction [ 4 ].…”

Anestesia en perros braquicefálicos: manejo preventivo de complicaciones frecuentes

“…Esta particular conformación genera un relativo exceso de tejidos blandos en el tracto respiratorio alto, responsable de la sintomatología clínica del síndrome respiratorio del braquicefálico (SORB). La mortalidad anestésica en perros de raza Bulldog Inglés (BDI), Francés (BDF) y Pug es mayor que en razas no braquicefálicas 1,2 . La anestesia de estos pacientes supone un desafío al momento de garantizar la permeabilidad de la vía aérea en las diferentes etapas de la anestesia, a fin de evitar la hipoxemia perioperatoria.…”