Performance of inhomogeneous Poisson point process models under different scenarios of uncertainty in species presence-only data

Abstract

Haphazard and opportunistic species occurrence (PO) data are widely used in species distribution models (SDMs) instead of high-quality species data gathered using appropriate and structured sampling methods, which is expensive and often spatially limited. Despite their widespread use in ecology, PO data are prone to errors and uncertainties, such as imperfect detectability, positional imprecision, and spatial niche truncation, which make their use analytically challenging for effective and adaptive biodiversity management and conservation. Using simulated data, this study investigates the effects of these uncertainties on the performance of spatial point process based presence-only and integrated SDMs. We investigated three SDMs in this study, one that ignores imperfect detectability: the presence-only model (PO model), and two that account for it: the thinned presence-only model (THINPO model) and the integrated model (PBPC model). The ability of these SDMs to produce accurate maximum likelihood estimates of intensity model coefficients and reliable predictions of species distributions under different data quality scenarios was investigated. The results show that SDMs that account for imperfect detectability (THINPO or PBPC models) are not applicable in situations of high detectability. In this situation, the PO model produces the most accurate maximum likelihood estimates of the models’ coefficients ($${\hat{\beta }}_k$$ β ^ k ), and consequently the most accurate predictions of species distributions ($${\hat{\lambda }}(s)$$ λ ^ ( s ) ). The effects of positional uncertainty and spatial niche truncation on this SDM output are minimal. However, in situations of low detectability, it is preferable to use the PBPC model. Positional uncertainty and spatial niche truncation have negligible effects on the output of this SDM, except when positionally uncertain PO data are analyzed along with truncated PC data. These minimal effects of spatial niche truncation on SDM outputs demonstrate the transferability of SDMs. However, the effects of all these uncertainties may depend on the characteristics of the species. Prior to modeling species distributions, a multivariate environmental similarity surface analysis should be performed to test the similarity between data from the restricted region to be used for model calibration and data from the entire range. If this analysis reveals dissimilarities, larger spatial and ecological scales should be considered to address the issue of spatial niche truncation. Further efforts could address the effects of species characteristics on SDMs performance and assess the effects of species-specific uncertainties.