Performance of Current Intensive Care Unit Ventilators During Pressure and Volume Ventilation

Abstract

During VA/C, tidal volume was set at 500 mL and inspiratory time was set at 0.8 second. Rise time and termination criteria were set at the manufacturers' defaults, and to an optimal level during PS and PA/C. RESULTS: There were marked differences in ventilator performance in all 3 modes. VA/C had the greatest difficulty meeting lung model demand and the greatest variability across all tested scenarios and ventilators. From high to low inspiratory muscle effort, pressure-to-trigger, time for pressure to return to baseline, and triggering pressuretime product decreased in all modes. With increasing resistance and decreasing compliance, tidal volume, pressure-to-trigger, time-to-trigger, time for pressure to return to baseline, time to 90% of peak pressure, and pressure-time product decreased. There were large differences between the default and optimal settings for all the variables in PS and PA/C. Performance was not affected by PEEP. CONCLUSIONS: Most of the tested ventilators performed at an acceptable level during the majority of evaluations, but some ventilators performed inadequately during specific settings. Bedside clinical evaluation is needed. Key words: ventilator; mechanical ventilation; intensive care; pressure support; pressure assist/control; volume assist/control. [Respir Care 2011;56(7):928 -940.

What is the role of noninvasive ventilation in cystic fibrosis?

“…Such information suggests that one ventilator may not suit all patients, nor may one ventilator provide optimal ventilation in individual patients as their clinical status changes and underlines the importance of regular clinical evaluation [21].…”

Reliability of manikin‐based studies: an evaluation of manikin characteristics and their impact on measurements of ventilatory variables

“…Many artificial lungs are able to simulate the entire respiratory system of an adult, allowing the setting of essential respiratory characteristics (lung compliance, airway resistance, etc). While the evaluation of some airway equipment can be carried out on a lung simulator alone , most studies connect it to a manikin to model the face and airways . Evaluation of the characteristics of the manikin is rarely undertaken, and to our knowledge, nobody has studied its impact on the data collected.…”

A bench evaluation of fraction of oxygen in air delivery and tidal volume accuracy in home care ventilators available for hospital use

“…The advantage of a turbine is that it means the ventilator can operate without high-pressure compressed air. The potential limitations of a turbine include the risk of the gas reaching a high temperature at the ventilator outlet, the lack of accuracy in F I O 2 when the oxygen is added, and the lack of accuracy V T delivery for patients with a marked impairment in respiratory mechanics (6). A previous bench study demonstrated acceptable temperatures at the outlets of turbine ventilators, and hence a very low risk of humidifier dysfunction (7).…”