Performance evaluation of nonhomogeneous hospitals: the case of Hong Kong hospitals

Abstract

Throughout the world, hospitals are under increasing pressure to become more efficient. Efficiency analysis tools can play a role in giving policymakers insight into which units are less efficient and why. Many researchers have studied efficiencies of hospitals using data envelopment analysis (DEA) as an efficiency analysis tool. However, in the existing literature on DEA-based performance evaluation, a standard assumption of the constant returns to scale (CRS) or the variable returns to scale (VRS) DEA models is that decision-making units (DMUs) use a similar mix of inputs to produce a similar set of outputs. In fact, hospitals with different primary goals supply different services and provide different outputs. That is, hospitals are nonhomogeneous and the standard assumption of the DEA model is not applicable to the performance evaluation of nonhomogeneous hospitals. This paper considers the nonhomogeneity among hospitals in the performance evaluation and takes hospitals in Hong Kong as a case study. An extension of Cook et al. (2013) [1] based on the VRS assumption is developed to evaluated nonhomogeneous hospitals' efficiencies since inputs of hospitals vary greatly. Following the philosophy of Cook et al. (2013) [1], hospitals are divided into homogeneous groups and the product process of each hospital is divided into subunits. The performance of hospitals is measured on the basis of subunits. The proposed approach can be applied to measure the performance of other nonhomogeneous entities that exhibit variable return to scale.

Data Envelopment Analysis Models in Non-Homogeneous Environment

“…Among the application-oriented papers, Huang et al (2016) presents a study on the evaluation of hotels in Taiwan with non-homogeneity in hotel types where the hotels are divided into two non-homogeneous groups. Li et al (2018) is an application paper that deals with efficiency evaluation of non-homogeneous Hong Kong hospitals. Sun et al (2017) presents an application of heterogeneous DEA models in performance evaluation of bank systems.…”

Efficiency, RTS, and marginal returns from salary on the performance of the NBA players: A parallel DEA network with shared inputs

“…Moreover, DEA gives the required information to move the inefficient DMUs to the efficient frontier [3]. DEA has been applied in various areas and applications such as sports [17,25], research and development (R&D) [1], banks [10], and hospitals [18].…”

Prevalence, Reasons, and Predisposing Factors Associated with 30-day Hospital Readmissions in Poland

“…Quality issues are a rapidly growing concern in the delivery of hospital services. Hospital financing constitutes the greatest share of health spending, making both policymakers and third-party payers (health insurers) more aware of the efficiency and quality of care delivered in inpatient settings [1,2,3,4]. In this context, a number of outcome-based quality measures have been proposed to assess the value for money in hospital care.…”