The Distinct Timing Hypothesis (DTH) proposes that two different neuronal computations underlie temporal information processing below and above one second. We tested DTH predictions by varying the interval between two visual events (S and C) from 400 to 2000 ms. To verify whether attentive encoding processes play a role, we deployed three durations for S (120, 160, and 200 ms), which map to attentive sampling frequencies of 8.33, 6.25, and 5 Hz. The one-second divide does not modulate sensory precision in duration discrimination, while it determines whether participants will dilate/compress perceived S duration. However, all distortion effects disappear when S is extended to 200 ms, suggesting that a sampling rate of 5 Hz optimizes subjective decisions. Since the effects of the one-second divide on perceived duration are not hardwired, a single computational mechanism may underlie both sub-second and supra-second temporal scales for behavior, in flexible interaction with attentive encoding processes.