Perceptions of risk in pregnancy with chronic disease: A systematic review and thematic synthesis

Abstract

Background Women with chronic disease are at increased risk of adverse pregnancy outcomes. Pregnancies which pose higher risk, often require increased medical supervision and intervention. How women perceive their pregnancy risk and its impact on health behaviour is poorly understood. The aim of this systematic review of qualitative literature is to evaluate risk perceptions of pregnancy in women with chronic disease. Methods Eleven electronic databases including grey literature were systematically searched for qualitative studies published in English which reported on pregnancy, risk perception and chronic disease. Full texts were reviewed by two researchers, independently. Quality was assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Qualitative checklist and data were synthesised using a thematic synthesis approach. The analysis used all text under the findings or results section from each included paper as data. The protocol was registered with PROSPERO. Results Eight studies were included in the review. Three themes with sub-themes were constructed from the analysis including: Information Synthesis (Sub-themes: Risk to Self and Risk to Baby), Psychosocial Factors (Sub-themes: Emotional Response, Self-efficacy, Healthcare Relationship), and Impact on Behaviour (Sub-themes: Perceived Risk and Objective Risk). Themes fitted within an overarching concept of Balancing Act. The themes together inter-relate to understand how women with chronic disease perceive their risk in pregnancy. Conclusions Women’s pregnancy-related behaviour and engagement with healthcare services appear to be influenced by their perception of pregnancy risk. Women with chronic disease have risk perceptions which are highly individualised. Assessment and communication of women’s pregnancy risk should consider their own understanding and perception of risk. Different chronic diseases introduce diverse pregnancy risks and further research is needed to understand women’s risk perceptions in specific chronic diseases.

Parenthood With Kidney Failure: Answering Questions Patients Ask About Pregnancy

“…14,19 Shared decision-making is essential and must reflect the patients' values and preferences, clinical context and complexity, the level of risk they are willing to accept, and the level of autonomy they desire. 7,8,15,20 Input from other clinicians who may be part of the future antenatal care team, especially highrisk pregnancy obstetricians, is recommended to cocreate a management plan. 12,21 Peer support is also highly valued by women, if available.…”

“…14 Whether to undertake a pregnancy posing potential hazards to maternal and infant health is a highly individualized decision. 20 Women balance the desire for motherhood with fears of fetal harm, impact of pregnancy on future health, and parenting while juggling the demands of their condition (including potentially reduced survival). The emotional, social, and ethical challenges are heightened when clinicians catastrophize about pregnancy risk or if they "forbid" it.…”

“…77 Quantifying and communicating pregnancy risk to women is an essential component of counseling. 20 In Figure 1, 42,[48][49][50]65,68,[78][79][80][81][82][83][84][85] we provide a contemporaneous "snapshot" of key perinatal and obstetrical outcomes for dialyzed and transplanted women, based on selected recent, larger studies of cohorts in developed countries. In Figure 2, we provide a "traffic light system" co-designed by patients from our Pregnancy Advisory Group.…”

A blueprint for a new model of sexual and reproductive health care in subspecialty medicine

“…Some subspecialists also choose not to discuss pregnancy termination because they are personally uncomfortable with the topic of abortion or fear legal consequences, 14 and this phenomenon will likely be potentiated in the wake of the Dobbs versus Jackson decision that overturned Roe versus Wade 61 . However, people feel that their SRH needs are best met when their clinicians are supportive, compassionate, and recognize their concerns; they feel that their needs are not met when their clinicians are directive, overly medicalized, or do not consider their priorities in reproductive decision making 26,27,29,62 …”

Pregnancy planning health information and service needs of women with chronic non-communicable conditions: a systematic review and narrative synthesis

“…Maternal NCDs are known to adversely affect reproductive outcomes and the proportion of women with chronic conditions giving birth is increasing [ 20 ]. For women living with NCDs, pregnancy decision making is more complex than for other women as they need to consider the additional potential risks of pregnancy on their own health and the heath of the fetus [ 21 ].…”