Perceptions of Customers as Sustained Competitive Advantages of Global Marketing Airline Alliances: A Hybrid Text Mining Approach

Abstract

Over the past several decades, the aviation industry has been reshaped, centering on global alliances, and these have grown exponentially. However, it is still not clear whether they are achieving sustained competitive advantages, and what are the specific competitive advantages of the three alliances (oneworld, SkyTeam, Star Alliance) arising on the customer side. This study aims to examine whether global alliance groups outperform the non-alliance group, how the three alliances differ regarding passengers’ perceptions, and what their competitive advantages are. A hybrid text mining analysis was adopted as this study’s method. Frequency tests, t-tests, one-way analysis of variance tests, and three-step mediated regression analyses were performed using 6393 ordinal and word-of-mouth (WOM) data. We found that the degree of passengers’ perceptions of alliances was low, the non-alliance group outperformed the alliance groups, and there were no significant differences between alliances on service rating and sentiment score. Only oneworld has competitive advantages that link to passengers’ service rating and sentiment score. These findings imply that alliances could not ensure competitive advantages that derive from customers’ perceptions, and although passengers partly perceived several selling points, their differentiation strategies are not successful.

Airline Cabin Crew Members’ Ambidexterity as the Sustainable Attitude for Prosocial Passenger Service

“…The airline business has faced challenges in improving profitability and passenger service due to fluctuating oil costs and unexpected external environments, such as global epidemics. In order to achieve a sustainable competitive advantage, many airlines provide differentiated in-flight services to their passengers [1][2][3]. Although airlines publish their service manuals after a long period of research and efforts, they need to continuously improve and update their manuals due to the dynamic environment of the aviation industry [4,5].…”

Do Ambient Conditions (Air Quality, Noise Level and Temperature) and Image Congruity Matter for Boosting Customer Approach Behaviors in the FSC Sector?

“…It is irrefutable that maximizing customer approach behaviors is an essential requisite of an airline company's successful management [10,11]. Preceding studies for the extant consumer behavior and marketing literature showed that providing a better quality physical environment to customers is one important way of eliciting positive post-consumption decisions/behaviors for the company [12][13][14][15].…”

Strategic Communication and Competitive Advantage: Assessing CEO Letters of Global Airline Alliances

“…As moves to strengthen competitiveness, airlines have participated in global airline alliances. A global airline alliance is "any cooperative arrangement among two or more global airlines to realize their strategic goals and improve their competitive advantages" (Seo and Itoh, 2020).…”